Guess which is graded higher (X-Men 94)

[fushi]

Hi all,

 

Been bored today. Thought I'd try something different. I am going to post 2 copies of X-Men #94. One is graded slightly higher than the other (both have same pq). Can you guess which higher/lower graded? I'll post the answer later.

 

Copy #1

 

Copy #2

[october]

I am going with....

 

copy 1: 7.5

 

copy 2: 7.0

[Sal]

copy 2 seems to be worse off to me...which makes me think you are trying to fool people.

 

instead of going through the whole "...never bet against a Sicilian when death is on the line" rigamarole, i'm going to stay with my original opinion....copy 2

 

[Mr. Zipper]

Copy 2 appears to be the lesser copy with the crescent crease at the top and some staining and possible foxing (bottom right front cover).

 

I'd say Copy 1 is a 7.0 and Copy 2 is a 6.0.

 

(I have a CGC 7.5 and Copy #1 appears to be slightly worse than my copy in terms of edgewear and creases.)

[uclapeterg]

Copy 1 is better

[-cryptkeeper-]

copy 1 is in better shape

[Khumbu]

#1 6.5

 

#2 6.0 simply because I had a very similar book come back 5.5

[ComicsAndCode]

Copy 1 is better. #1 6.0 , #2 5.5

[fushi]

ok..this was obviously too easy for ya'lll

 

October nailed the grades.

 

[october]

ok..this was obviously too easy for ya'lll

 

October nailed the grades.

 

Booya!!!