Please grade this Amazing Spiderman #54!

[Point Five]

Having trouble fine-tuning the grade on this one...see what you guys think.

Really glossy flat book, but there's a color scuff (not a chip) in the ULC, creasing LRC and some corner rounding. What sayest thou?

 

 

 

[herald2galactus]

i go 6.0

[Comicdey]

looks trimmed in the 2nd image.

[Point Five]

[Dad&Son-migration]

looks trimmed in the 2nd image.

 

That's a fair assessment Collin. I looked it over after you said that but IMO I wouldn't say it was trimmed. myself. I was thinking the grade was along the lines of 5.5.

[Owls Head]

5.5/6.0 yes something like that maybe 6.0

[Dad&Son-migration]

After looking at it again I would certainly agree with ol' Herald and Owls Head and say 6.0

[Comicdey]

[Dad&Son-migration]

 

I must be on crack because I thought you were serious.. but I get the idea, cropped image.. jokes actually on me now

[-cryptkeeper-]

sweet 6.0

[alexml.]

Call me conservative, but based on the corner creases lower right I wouldn't go above 5.5.

[Point Five]

[Comicdey]

 

Back cover looks like a 6.5, front cover looks like a 5.5...........I'd still give it an overall strong 5.5, weak 6.0 (not trimmed )

[Point Five]

Sounds like you guys are coming out right where I am...the book is right on the edge of 6.0, but not sure it squeaks in. In hand the positives definitely suggest 6.0 even with the flaws, but probably call it 5.5 to be safe.

 

Thanks, everyone!

[-cryptkeeper-]

Sounds like you guys are coming out right where I am...the book is right on the edge of 6.0, but not sure it squeaks in. In hand the positives definitely suggest 6.0 even with the flaws, but probably call it 5.5 to be safe.

 

Thanks, everyone!

 

you can't be wrong with 6.0 , nice book

[marvelcollector]

Gotta go with a 5.5..I was all set to give it the FN, then I saw the 2 creases LRFC....