Here's a CAP 105 to grade:

[CosmicBob]

Here's my other raw book for y'all to grade:

 

http://www.avalonconsulting.biz/comics/images/cap105a.jpg

http://www.avalonconsulting.biz/comics/images/cap105b.jpg

 

If you can't see it, there's a subscription crease in it (bleh). It looked better in the bag.

 

I have no clue what to give this one. Stupid subscription crease. I'm not certain why I bought this in the first place. It was years ago when I was trying to get a nice run of early Caps. Obviously, this one isn't "nice".

 

Thanks for your help!

[uclapeterg]

VG/F?

[icecube-migration]

Good, rounded corners, stress marks, edges are rippled and there might be a crease in the middle of the book? Can't really tell...ED

[CosmicBob]

There's a HUGE subscription crease right down the middle of the thing.

[ninanina]

At least a VG with the crease. Possibly a VG/F, but no better.

[supapimp]

agreed with general concensus, VG/FN 5.0 due to HUGE sub crease

[Tomega]

I would go with a 4.0 at most I just cannot see it falling into the 5.0 because of the crease and the spine. I did not think full length creases are permitted in anything higher then 4.0 especially with the accumulation of those other defects. It reminds me of the books on pages 261 and 262 of the most recent Overstreet Grading guide.

 

Tom