GRADING CONTEST : Round 3

[Silvers24]

Holy *spoon*! Man, I did it again. Missed by .2

[sterlingcomics]

....knocked it down wayyyy too much for BC soiling....

 

I've made that mistake before. From previous contests I've learned that CGC doesn't really downgrade for that.

 

 

The back cover could look black and CGC wouldn't count off. It's a big deal with me though.

[Pirate]

Round 3 is now closed.

 

Grades submitted were:

 

7.0 - 1

 

7.5 - 1

 

8.0 - 12

 

8.5 - 21

 

9.0 - 30

 

9.2 - 27

 

9.4 - 7

 

9.6 - 2

 

 

First huge props to FlamingTelapath, I bought this book from his Ebay auctions advertized as a VF/NM

 

the result

 

I have 9.0's with corners like that

[mar-vell]

oh man.. the pressure of a contest

 

don't sweat it we both know each of us are competent graders- the problem is everybody has a slight variation in standards--CGC is the industry standard but they are not the be-all end-all of comics grading!

[Flaming_Telepath]

Round 3 is now closed.

 

Grades submitted were:

 

7.0 - 1

 

7.5 - 1

 

8.0 - 12

 

8.5 - 21

 

9.0 - 30

 

9.2 - 27

 

9.4 - 7

 

9.6 - 2

 

 

First huge props to FlamingTelapath, I bought this book from his Ebay auctions advertized as a VF/NM

 

the result

 

 

 

 

Great contest, BTW, Nik!

 

Now, could you just stop submitting my books...it's making me ill.

[divad]

I think you overgraded it . . .

[toro]

Guess I need to get new reading glasses(or my current ones cleaned) ! I wasn't even in the ballpark on this one. I thought overgraded it at 8.5!

[piper]

Guess I need to get new reading glasses(or my current ones cleaned) ! I wasn't even in the ballpark on this one. I thought overgraded it at 8.5!

 

I clearly suck at this! I picked 8.5 also.

[CW]

What did I say Nik, 3rd times a charm!

[Mad Dog]

[-cryptkeeper-]

9.4

 

you're a lucky man Nik

[Theagenes]

....knocked it down wayyyy too much for BC soiling....

 

Me too!

[Monstro]

is there any way we can just start this whole *spoon* thing over with

[Monstro]

kidding

[Mad Dog]

is there any way we can just start this whole *spoon* thing over with

 

[Paratrooper]

Round 3 is now closed.

 

Grades submitted were:

 

7.0 - 1

 

7.5 - 1

 

8.0 - 12

 

8.5 - 21

 

9.0 - 30

 

9.2 - 27

 

9.4 - 7

 

9.6 - 2

 

 

First huge props to FlamingTelapath, I bought this book from his Ebay auctions advertized as a VF/NM

 

 

arghhh VF/NM is what I graded it too, dagnabit

[Sid]

WOO!

I was losing hope after Round 2.

[UKavenger]

Missed the first two rounds... don't know how!! Fair way off on this too! Just have to watch these 5 furlong horses fall by the wayside as the long distancer's make their way up on the rails!!!

[Owls Head]

Missed the first two rounds... don't know how!! Fair way off on this too! Just have to watch these 5 furlong horses fall by the wayside as the long distancer's make their way up on the rails!!!

 

here's to the closers running down the speed horses dueling on the front end...

 

[Sal]

Missed the first two rounds... don't know how!! Fair way off on this too! Just have to watch these 5 furlong horses fall by the wayside as the long distancer's make their way up on the rails!!!

 

here's to the closers running down the speed horses dueling on the front end...

 

 

my horse is halfway to the glue factory at this point