Game: SILVER AGE SURVIVOR SERIES - Round 6

[richnerd]

Are all the Marvel fans clear that Adventure #247 (which makes a bizarre comeback after being left off the last poll) is up for DELETION this round?

 

roger that i more vote for the adventure to end now!

 

Whats an Adventure #247? bye bye.. one vote closer!

[joe_collector]

Good work guys, and once again:

 

ADVENTURE COMICS 274 is marked for DELETION by any and all comic fans.

[Pirate]

Adventure 247 is a very important SA book, can't believe it has that many votes.

[joe_collector]

Adventure 247 is a very important SA book.

 

Oh, and FF 2 and AT 27 aren't? You can laugh at Antman all you want, but he's one of the earliest Marvel SA heroes, a member of the original Avengers, and a very important cog in their history.

 

At this level, all the books have some level of importance.

[Lazyboy]

FF 2 and TTA 27 should not be gone yet. Neither should Adventure 247. Flash 105 and JLA 1, however...

 

Actually, if not for the book introducing JJJ AND his son AND the Chameleon, as well as being the beginning of Spidey's first title, I might even kick ASM 1 out before most of those.

[Guardian Comics]

Any issue that is #105 and doesn't include a 1st appearance of the title character has to go At least Adventure #247 includes a 1st appearance, granted a 1st appearance of a team that nobody cares about (unless you are over the age of 60)but a first appearance nonetheless

 

Jim

[Comicdey]

I voted flash 105.....begone speedster...you still have a showcase to dwell on.

[JohnT]

Adventure 247 is a very important SA book.

 

Oh, and FF 2 and AT 27 aren't? You can laugh at Antman all you want, but he's one of the earliest Marvel SA heroes, a member of the original Avengers, and a very important cog in their history.

 

At this level, all the books have some level of importance.

 

I wouldn't call Ant-man a cog. Maybe an oddity, or a historical footnote. If he was a cog, they wouldn't have changed him to Giant man trying to drum up some interest.

 

I'm still thinking about the next round. I'm not sure I get the anti-Legion crowd. They were the first SA superhero group, predating JLA by 2 years. That's pretty significant. And they ended up being popular for years in Adventure, Superboy, and their own titles. On the other hand, we're running out of options. Maybe Hulk #1. That title was canceled after 6 issues.

[Sal]

the Legion was also the first NEW super-hero group, instead of a bunch of guys and gals from their own titles getting together.

 

i'm voting for Pym to go until he does. makes me feel good inside

[Silverspider]

Begone DC camp! Another vote for Adventure 247! 3 rounds in a row.

 

Early prediction, Suspense 39 is going to take the whole thing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Aman619]

its cool how each round reveals the next round's contestants, or likely losers.

Or maybe, not so cool, since it skews the voting... by focusing the spotlite of shame on the almost losers of each round.

 

I think I said the same thing 2 rounds ago?

[-cryptkeeper-]

adventure 247

[chrisco37]

Adios to the Ant. He didn't even have his costume yet.

 

Plus, he's so "second tier" (heck, he might even be thrid tier as far as I'm concerned). The only time I've ever been remotely interested in him is when they changed him into the biggest *spoon* ever in Ultimates.

[heinlein99]

Yeah, wow, I can't believe the Legion might be gone after the next vote.

[sborock]

Yeah, wow, I can't believe the Legion might be gone after the next vote.

 

Yeah, the 4th appearance of the JLA is soooo much more important

 

I think people like it because JLA left the # 1 off the cover

[Norrin_Radd]

"Concentrate all firepower on TTA #27!"

 

 

[paperheart]

squish- what's that under my shoe?

[tth2]

squish- what's that under my shoe?

A spider?

[paperheart]

squish- what's that under my shoe?

A spider?

 

so soon?

[tth2]

squish- what's that under my shoe?

A spider?

 

so soon?

I fully recognize the importance of AF 15 and wouldn't vote for it until the very end. The second appearance of Spider-Man, however (and a krappy cover to boot)...