ASM 16, 17, 22

[trmoore54]

ASM 16 This one was graded by Heritage...see if you can cite the same grade...

 

ASM 17 2nd Gobby

 

ASM 22 very clean!

[Dad&Son-migration]

ASM #16 - I'm going to say 5.0 (VG/FN) and assume Heritage said 6.0 (Fine)

 

ASM #17 - 4.5

ASM #22 - 6.5

 

[trmoore54]

Good guess on the 16...exactly right...I'd give it a 5.5

Why so harsh on the 22? What are the detracting factors you detect?

[Dad&Son-migration]

I would say the ASM #22 would've been a 7.5 but I took a full 1.0 off for what appears to be a very heavy impact crease to the lower left corner which would run thru the interior pages as well. Just an assumption.

by the way... what did heritage grade the ASM #16 Did they say 6.0

[trmoore54]

On the 22, I don't believe that's the case but I'll go back and double-check...if so I would tend to agree with you but probably lean toward 7.0...

As for the Heritage...Yep...6.0...HA!

[Aces]

ASM #16 - I'm going to say 5.0 (VG/FN) and assume Heritage said 6.0 (Fine)

 

ASM #17 - 4.5

ASM #22 - 6.5

 

Once again complete agreement.

5.0 - 4.5 - 6.5

[Aces]

On the 22, I don't believe that's the case but I'll go back and double-check...if so I would tend to agree with you but probably lean toward 7.0...

As for the Heritage...Yep...6.0...HA!

 

So you are unhappy with the 16?

Is it for sale?

[trmoore54]

On the 22, I don't believe that's the case but I'll go back and double-check...if so I would tend to agree with you but probably lean toward 7.0...

As for the Heritage...Yep...6.0...HA!

 

So you are unhappy with the 16?

Is it for sale?

 

I've had it for a couple of years...I'm pretty happy with it and got it for a reasonable price at the time (less than a hundred bucks)...I think it presents very well when held in hand...

Isn't everything always for sale?

I will make larger scans of the front and back cover and PM you and you can see if you're interested...