• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

PDidds

Member
  • Posts

    52
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by PDidds

  1. On 5/17/2024 at 1:08 AM, comicginger1789 said:

    I can see your point to a degree. Also though, standards of grading have changed. It is not a static thing and many things have changed from even a decade ago. Hence why a re-grade is needed. For example certain flaws are more forgiveable so there is a chance your green labelled 4.0 with a signature on it could now be considered a 4.5-5.0 based on current grading practices. Personally, I would be happy to have updated eyes take a look at the book.

    I can see the frustration in a book graded only a few years ago having to go through the process again but all of it is a safety measure. CGC got rocked with scandal and the last thing they need is another person trying one where they submit wrong books inside slabs. CGC just copying the grade without checking it over opens the door for problems that they do not want to deal with again.

    Good points -- but everything you raise is a CGC problem NOT a customer's problem.  Why make it a customer's problem by making us pay?  MONOPOLY CASH GRAB.  CGC knows they're the only dog in the hunt and while they are very cool about a lot of things, and I praise them regularly, this is just robbery.

  2. On 5/10/2024 at 4:37 AM, MattM CS said:

    If you would like these to be receive a CGCxJSA authenticated signature, the books will need to be resubmitted through a grading tier. This service is not available for reholder submissions. 

    THIS is BS and a CASH GRAB. !!

    Pay for a REHOLDER - yes -- Pay for a JSA verification - Yes -- but PAY to have the same friggin grade put on the book !! Hell NO!!  That absolute robbery!!  What is changing?  You guys graded the book already and were paid for the grading.  Now you want to be paid a 2nd time to grade a book you already graded?  Did you damage it when you removed it from the green label slab?  Why do you need to re- grade it?  Robbery!  Extremely unethical.

    To drive interest in the new label you guys SHOULD BE offering special incentives to have all the green labels re submitted.  Get these new labels out there in circulation and on eBay etc.  But often the forest can't be seen thru the cash grab.

    I will NOT be submitting any of my GREEN label books.  

  3. On 5/15/2024 at 9:53 AM, Ron C. said:

    Yes. Hopefully right across the chest.

    yeah -- I'm excited to see my book.   I asked for "fun" colored pens.  Hugh plus the 50th signing.   

    I saw one guy had his cover all taped up with exact little boxes where he wanted people to sign.  Very structured.

     

     

  4. On 4/30/2024 at 7:06 AM, The Element Man said:

    image.png.d9452ea5e4077b5e3756be2e3d8a8ab6.png

    HA !!

    Look at all the POPs in the back ground.  The collectibles market is definitely going to be flooded with "signed" junk from Hugh.

  5. S-Man -- they've told me multiple different dates multiple times for multiple excuses. Mostly they throw Celebrity Authentics under the bus and say it's their problem and that CGC is absolved of any responsibility in the matter.

    All I know - I sent my book to CGC.  CGC took my money.  CGC isn't compensating anyone for the excessive delays.  CGC isn't communicating with their customers about it in any professional manner - I mean just post an update once in a while "we apologize for the continued delay...".  CGC won't allow me to have the book sent to other signings while they have possession of it.  It's just locked away in the Hugh Jackman closet.  So, I'm just wanting to know when he's coming out of the closet. 

    (lol)

     

  6. There used to be a thread here and I can't find it anymore.  It's been over a year.  No updates from CGC  - just passing the back to Celebrity Authentics.  In the mean time, I've missed the opportunity to get my Woverine #1 signed my Miller, Claremont. - Twice !!

    Honestly -- CGC should cancel the signing and resolicit the event if it ever gets scheduled again.

  7. It's booked through CELEBRITY AUTHENTICS who have a history of writing proverbial cheques they can't cash.   The group gets an extremely flexible agreement from a celebrity / athlete etc, not much more than a handshake, really.  But their time does get booked and confirmed with their agent/manager, so typically this means it will happen.  It's just not a priority - and the level of BS excuses we get as the fan/consumer is terrible.   Personally, I don't believe this will happen in February either.  They've clearly booked the time with Jackman as a charity event to satisfy some of his tax deduction/offset obligations.  

  8. What the frack!   Seriously!   There’s likely no better time to get Hugh Jackman in to sign comic books than right now while there’s an ongoing actors strike.  He’s out there posting social media pics of himself doing the most mundane stuff.  Why isn’t someone confirming him or canceling him for this signing?! CGC has taken my money, I’m not earning any interest on it, I can’t spend it on something else, etc. (it’s just the principle, really).    AND I’ve missed a Frank Miller and a Chris Claremont signing for the same book while it’s been in cold storage at cgc.  Very annoying.  

  9. On 8/7/2023 at 2:02 PM, mr_highgrade said:

    I met Hugh Jackman 3 times here in NYC before and after his broadway shows. He signed for me on two different occasions on 2 different X-men  & Old Man Logan books. The first time he gave me his autograph, he told me If I told anyone he was gonna kill me. :eek:

    My (ex)wife and I were at his San Francisco show in 2011(?).  I left the show at the encore to get near front of line for the "leaving" signing he was going to do.  Before he came out, they announced "Hugh will sign one item and the Playbill but will not pose for photos" -- my wife desperately wanted a photo.  As he came to us (we were maybe the 5th or 6th person), he'd already said NO to two photo requests -- so he got to us and (I'm Australian) I asked "hey mate, any way for a pic with my wife - we're all the way from Tasmania...".   He gave me an eye roll look and a smile "okay - real quick - Tassie is pretty far away".   As the photo was taken, the crowd started to stir up, so he announced "no - they were from Tasmania!" -- then some woman way in the back screamed "I'm from Darwin!!", so he called her up, took a few pictures with a few others and then called security in to calm the rush.  So, Hugh will always be a top pick for me when it comes to "cool celebs".  --- But he's testing my patience with this friggin' cgc signing....

    IMG_5023.jpeg

  10. On 7/8/2023 at 9:12 AM, atrocitus said:

    I’m gonna see one of the guys from Celebrity Authentics next week so I’m gonna ask him if the Downey will ever happen. I’m 35 dollars into it and if it ever happens it will cost me another 335. I can hold out a while longer lol

    There's no way DOWNEY is signing for $370 today.   Even if they managed to schedule him he'd be around $1,000 each sig.  I know you've got a "deposit" but it won't mean spit.

  11. I agree.  CGC needs to own their work, accept ownership of previous 9.8 grades, etc.   

    If a book is merely cracked and signed -- then slabbed -- it should get the same grade as it came in with.   

    If the book is submitted with a request for pressing as well as a signature - it should be graded again.  Only people hoping up the grade are paying for pressing.

    It makes ZERO sense books get downgraded.

  12. I don't understand why BLACK is the go to marker.   It looks terrible on most covers.  The SIGNATURE TEAM at cgc should be a little more aware of their surroundings - when they present the book to the person signing, cgc should have a recommended marker in-hand.   I know these people sign thousands of books in hours -- but the consumer is paying good money and often the result is sub-par because of the color of ink - a tiny bit of extra effort                                      

    Just my opinion, your mileage may vary