ROBTOTHEC

Yep! 5.5

Probably 4.0 IMHO...

7.0 IMHO...

The Eye Appeal on this book looks nicer than the technical grade would probably be. 4.0/4.5

3.0 as is. I don't believe a C&P would be worth spending the money on.

+1

I'm also at 7.5

Is the book somewhat wavy or curled? Looks that way in the pics. 9.2

Heavily Stained? If anything there is a very slight barely noticeable "rubbing" transfer. There is no type of staining unless I misunderstand what it is you are trying to point out?

Since I was the owner of the book when I sent it in, I paged through the entire book as well as the other 9 that I sent. I pre-graded what I thought they would be. Having said that I have been unbelievably accurate with about 40-50 that I have submitted to CGC. I had pretty big variances with the ones I sent to CBCS. In no way did I think this book was a 7.0 or close or I never would have submitted it. I had the same with a Batman #227 that I was sure was an 8.0. Even the CBCS rep that was at the convention when I submitted kept saying, "that's a really nice copy especially with the black cover." I asked him if he thought it was an 8.0 and he said I'm not supposed to say but I think you're pretty spot on. It came back 6.0!?? So yes, I think I am going to crack them open and send them to CGC. I've been much happier with them.

The notes say nothing about any interior tears or writing or anything else.

Right, that is why I said the Thor #165 looks like 8.5/9.0! Either way how can the same grading company call them both 7.0? This is what makes professional grading so frustrating and not accurate.

I bought the TOS #49 at Motor City last may. I get home and compare it to a Thor #165 i submitted myself that to me looked 8.5/9.0? Can anyone explain how these are both 7.0? Should I send one or both to CGC instead? I'm baffled and very disappointed. I bought the TOS #49 at Motor City Con last May. I get home There is nothing hidden. Back covers show just like front. No tears or creases, etc...

Very happy with this one!

I'm really happy with this book!! Much nicer than the 2.5/3.0 that I am upgrading too.

6.0 IMHO...

Looks like a 4.5 to me?

That's too nice of a book to grade below a Fine IMHO. I'm at 6.5!

PLease take a look at my accurately graded and low starting bids books on EBAY! https://www.ebay.com/sch/m.html?item=292470099780&_ssn=com1cman1ac&_sop=1&_ipg=100&rt=nc

JUSTICE LEAGUES NOW LISTED WITH MANY MORE HIGH GRADES COMING!!

Here is a large Silver Age run of World's Finest always starting at very low starting bids. Nice Justice LEague run coming up starting with #15. https://www.ebay.com/sch/m.html?item=292470099780&_ssn=com1cman1ac&_sop=1&_ipg=100&rt=nc

For your consideration is this nice Doom Patrol run mostly mid-grade with some higher grade examples. Your satisfaction is guaranteed! Take a look! https://www.ebay.com/sch/m.html?item=292470099780&_ssn=com1cman1ac&_sop=1&_ipg=100&rt=nc

I have an incomplete but HIGH GRADE run of UNEXPECTED! Going to see if anyone on here is interested before I go to Feebay. wins first, or PM me. Paypal is preferred. If you want them all, make an offer?? UNEXPECTED #114 NEAR MINT 9.4 with absolute WHITE PAGES! ASKING PRICE $40 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #116 NEAR MINT 9.4 With WHITE PAGES! WRIGHTSON ART! ASKING PRICE $40 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #120 VERY FINE NEAR MINT 9.0 With WHITE PAGES! ASKING PRICE $20 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #122 NEAR MINT- 9.2 With WHITE PAGES! ASKING PRICE $30 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #124 NEAR MINT- 9.2/9.4 With WHITE PAGES! ASKING PRICE $32 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #126 NEAR MINT 9.4 With WHITE PAGES! 52 Pages ASKING PRICE $40 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #128 NEAR MINT+ 9.6 With OW to WHITE PAGES! WRIGHTSON ART! ASKING PRICE $50 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #129 NEAR MINT+ 9.6! With OW to WHITE PAGES! ASKING PRICE $40 Shipping $5 UNEXPECTED #130 NEAR MINT+ 9.6 With OW to WHITE PAGES! ASKING PRICE $40 Shipping $5