i8beef

Don't suppose the magneto cover one you got had an extra Claremont signature on it did it? My ME order had two cyc/wolverine covers erroneously sent to me, but neither one was mine, and both were direct and not newsstand....

Yes you do. Customer ID ME submission ID 4380678, Order number CGC1791079143. Note while this probably makes Fixer7640 whole, this is only one of the set of four messed up on my case though, so you guys are still investigating my other three apparently.

I am 99% that is one of my 4 missing X-Men #1s that had Claremont signatures... the Claremont signature looks absolutely identical (checked against previous image I had). The ones I got back were someone else's books, and have been sent back for ME already. The copy of that book I got back had two new signatures from Lee / Williams, did NOT have my Claremont sig though the label said it did with the date of my original Claremont signature... I'm not sure how to get CGC to connect the dots on this, but I'll mention this thread in my email chain with them, if you're lucky the copy of this I got was yours.

I sent in 7 books for the Lee / Williams signature series, four matched variants of X-Men #1 which already had CGC verified Chris Claremont signatures on them, and raw copies of X-Men #2, #3 and #5. I just got the shipment back, and immediately noticed that the X-Men #1 set wasn't mine... (a) because they literally sent me books with covers A, B, C and C instead of a D... but also (b) because while the holders say its signed by all three people, the Chris Claremont signatures are pretty obviously not there. It caught my eye on the shipment notice on the images too but I hoped the images were just wrong, but nope, wrong books, in the wrong holders, and one of them, which I had originally in a 9.8 grade, had dropped to a 9.4 with grader notes of "Crease on back cover"... which wasn't on MY book, but ALSO isn't on THIS book. Also, I'm like 90% the #2 I sent in was a direct and not the newstand that was sent back to me... but I dont have proof on that one, so I may have to accept it I guess? I sent a contact form in which is what it looked like their docs said to do but haven't heard back yet, but I'm a little concerned as the entire point was to have MY books signed, not just A book. Anyone hit this and had luck actually getting their books returned correctly? Is there anything else I should be doing, as I see CGC seems to have some strict time limits on trying to handle issues, and this is a big one.