WillowManson

I wish my books in way better condition would come back with 9.2's like that.................

I just had an issue returned and there is a mark on the cover that was not there when i shipped it out. I am waiting to hear back from them.

That is a brutal grade for that issue. I would give it a 7.5 to 7 based on all the imperfections I see. Anything in the 6 range would require major folds or bends or creases in the covers or major tears that can be seen in my opinion.

As the title says I am super disgusted with the latest returns I got. I submitted several issues that were bought pre-bagged and boarded and never read for collecting purposes back in the day and they all came back as 8.5 to 9.0. Issues include Amazing Spiderman # 375, Fantastic 4 # 265, 2 copies of Unlimited Spiderman # 1 and Legends of the Darkclaw # 1. I am trying to wrap my head around how these comics can come back with those lower grades when you can clearly see they are in near perfect condition in their cgc case. Whats worse is when you scan the code it shows issues with the comics I cannot see what so ever. I am now stuck with a butt load of comics that I will barely get my money back on from paying for grading when trying to re-sell them. What sucks is I bought and collected these comics when I was a kid as a future investment for retirement and now CGC is runing my retirement plans with their crappy grading. I may give them one more chance but if it is strike 3 on those returns they will never get my business again.