youfoundjake

3 bulleyes and a whiff on kid comics..

5 points, I will take it pretty much not overthinking it any more (other than holy cow there are a lot of grades near each other for this batch)

Headline Comics #11  6.0  me 6.5  +1

Out of the Shadows #8  4.0  me 3.0  +2

Fight Comics #28  5.0  Me 5.5   +1

My Romantic Adventures #68 6.5  me 6.0  +1

Nature Boy #3  7.0  Me 7.0

I got the notification @Get Marwood & I

Add me to the list

I'd like to try again this time.  Perhaps I won't miss the first set again.

oops, forgot to check in, good luck everyone.

On 6/12/2023 at 7:27 PM, ttfitz said:

Just curious - do you count the Showcase issues in for your quest?

I am missing two of the Showcase issues (4 and 8) as well as 112. #132 is on my list as I recently discovered my copy has some defect that I either missed (like a missing centerfold) or didn't care about at the time but decided was just too rough, even for me (who doesn't have high standards, with many 2.0 or 2.5 books in the collection as long as they aren't awful).

I wouldn't be against including the Showcase issues.  105-350 is the run I want to complete ultimately.

1. ADAMANTIUM

2. zzutak

3. scburdet

4. grendelbo 

5. Mars 76

6. jbpez

7. youfoundjake

Thanks for doing this Mike.

While I'm not happy with my performance, I appreciate the time that you have put into this and kudo's to all that completed it, regardless of your score.

ugh:

Looney Tunes #5 7.5   (1)

Rex the Wonder Dog #31  7.0  (2)

Batman #156  6.5   (6)

Spidey #78 8.5  (2)

Daredevil #168 9.0   (1)

12 points, how horrible is that ?

Didn't over think it, 2 bullseyes and 4 points total.

much better this round than last round. 

Every new list, I appear lower and lower in number, which makes sense, because that usually mirrors my grading abilities as the contest progresses..

I wanna play!

Loved  God Loves, Man Kills, but surprised no one posted this classic?  

Congrats to you both, you are both #3 in our hearts.

I consistently got worse with each round, so for the next contest, I recommend only one round.  Or, hear my out, maybe we start with Round 4, and I get better each round.  Either way works for me.

bump to bring back to first page due to massive posts

bump to bring back to first page due to massive posts

ugh

Why are they all the same grade? 

grades in...

That Wonder Woman killed me, why did I give it a 6.5? 

ugh

A little rushed on this one, wanted to do a second guess, but meh, throw something at the wall and see what sticks..

good start, I learned from the last one we did in 2022. Thanks for doing this Mike!

I wanna play!