Lost

2.5/3.0 for me too

8.5

5.0

My first sales thread. I don't sell a lot, so be kind. First "I'l take it" takes it regardless of my ability to speedily respond in DM's Payment: Paypal, venmo Who can buy: anyone! Shipping: Free within the US. Returns: none World of Suspense #1 CGC 6.0 $350.00 Battlefront #1 CGG 4.0 (restored) $70.00 (slight color touch? Maybe can be removed?) Mystical Tales #1 CGC 5.5 (restored) $100.00 (glue reattaching cover. not sure if it can be removed to get this to a blue) World of Mystery #1 CGC 3.5 $100.00 (prettiest 3.5 ever...CGC says stains, They do not present at all...no idea) DEAL - all 4 for $450.00! Please don't chat in this thread. I literally ignore threads where I have to endlessly scroll past comments.

5.0

7.5

5, but a nice 5!

5.5

I'm at a 4.5/5. Anyone else play the game where you ignore the replies and come up with your own then look at what other people said?

I think part of the issue is your are picking straws over a book CGC has already weighed in on. It's really based on if you can accept the book and the grade. The spine has a split from the grader notes which tells me it has probably rolled from being stored improperly. Also if you look closely there are spine tics from when the book did have the spine in the right position. With the ink, yes it could be ink. It doesn't diminish the appeal on my end. Does it diminish it for you?

8.0

9

9.6

4.5

3.0

3.5

5.5

4.0

was it like that when you submitted?

7.0

Themlh1138, You came seeking a grade!!..Instead you have found only--DISAGREEMENT!! Seriously I can be swayed lower if thats moisture damage which I missed. Nice book even still. On my bucket list...

6.5

9.4

9.2

I'd give it 6.5.