• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Sideshow Bob

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    757

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by Sideshow Bob

    Don Newton Bats/Tec gallery update

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob

    23 minutes ago, NelsonAI said:

    Congratulations Bob !!!

    I always loved the Newton / Alcala artistic combo.  Some people thought Alcala over powered Newton's pencils but I viewed it as no different than Sinnott inking Kirby on FF.

    DC included the story of the 366 cover in the editorial letters page.  Simonson did the commission at a show, someone from DC saw it and decided to use it as an inventory cover.

    A lot of folks were looking for this cover so Dave M was  one fortunate dude that Jim W contacted him.

    Cheers!

    N.

     

    Since I hadn't seen the original inks or knew the backstory, the published cover was my only reference until now. So my childhood pretense of how this cover got created was that Walt had been tasked with the cover duties. However, the rough storyline they gave him was Joker and Batman having their big fight on top of a temple, so he drew a Greek temple (the fight is on top of a Mayan pyramid in Guatemala). Jump back to today, and seeing the clear lines of the OA, it is very clearly a skyscraper with Greek god carvings and windows highlighted by police spotlights, and has zero connection to the story other than Batman and Joker duking it out. And one of my favorite Batman covers was an at-show commission, traded for cost of a new tractor. Hahaha. Never meet your heroes. LOL.

    Don Newton Bats/Tec gallery update

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob

    I talked to Walt about that Bats #366 cover a month ago, and he told me the story of using it as barter with his friend who had then sold it.  He didn't mention seeing it on Dave Mandel's wall... but I got a good laugh out of the fact that its location was sitting on a Felix YouTube video all this time. Knowing it is in Mandel's house closes the loop on it, but it also makes it 99.9% unobtainable. Was not knowing where it was all these years any better than knowing it's held in esteem by a top collector? Feels like if Schroedinger collected OA... 

    • Popular Post
    • Popular Post

    Don Newton Bats/Tec gallery update

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob
    Dangling preposition.

    No surprise to many here that I've been a big Don Newton fan for quite a while. But as I was trying to find a couple more pages to two specific issues from his Batman/Detective run, I hadn't shared all the art I'd picked up in the massive Ebay dump of 2017/2018. Call it pandemic fatigue, but the sequential art is just too good not to share. Obviously, I'd welcome any suggestions on where any missing pages might be, but the time for holding these in the shadows is well past its prime.

    My many thanks to Felix Liu for providing guidance on whether I should really attack that never-ending drip-drip sale in 2017/2018 on Ebay, even though I had to sell some quality pieces and put a couple buys on a credit card to fund the acquisition process (a single page was posted for sale every three days). "You'll kick yourself later if you don't!" from Felix gave me the push I needed...and the credit cards were quickly paid off. The evolution of a buyer of OA, to a broad collector of OA, to a focused collector of OA, to a curator of certain pieces or artists or runs, is a long process, full of mistakes and missteps. I'm not there yet, but definitely jumping in with both feet to acquire these interiors was a decision I'm glad I made.  

    Added 10 pages from Detective Comics #526 (May 1983) https://www.comicartfans.com/galleryroom.asp?gsub=208912

    Detective #526, the mega-sized 500th Batman-in-Detective anniversary issue, was a tour de force for Newton on pencils and inks by Alfredo Alcala and features a full run-through of Batman's Rogues Gallery. In my opinion, Newton's best work was really allowed to shine through with a significantly lighter touch by Alcala.

    Added 9 pages from Batman #366 (Dec 1983) https://www.comicartfans.com/galleryroom.asp?gsub=208911

    Batman #366 is the first appearance of Jason Todd as Robin, emerging as Bruce Wayne's blonde-haired new ward after his acrobat parents are killed (familiar setup?), but later retconned in Batman #408 as an orphaned black-haired tire thief until Death in the Family and a 900-number stunt put Batman into a pretty rough grieving period. Lots and lots of Alcala's trademark hatching and shading in this issue as story was set in the jungle atop temple ruins.

     

    Again, if you know where any pages are from these two issues that are not on CAF, let me know! Walt Simonson's cover to Bats #366 is out there somewhere [SOLVED] ...and that DPS from 'Tec #526 and several key pages from Bats #366 are unaccounted.

    Bob

    image.png.89871e83b88cedff6fe9c2d101656c0c.pngimage.png.5955aa815740929e684b575d8e36d709.png

    July Heritage Auction Sorta Shaping Up!

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted

    On 6/29/2020 at 1:41 PM, Sideshow Bob said:

    And the Batman #313 cover....Heritage says "This is possibly an alternate cover that was either reconfigured in production or rejected in order to maintain editorial consistency with the characters." 

    OK, so does anyone know if this is a rejected cover that had to be redrawn completely and there a clean version of this in the wild? Or did the background get flipped in production with a very good Exacto + a new suit pattern was applied?  I haven't taken the time yet to overlay them in Photoshop and see how the lines look in obverse. 

    UPDATE FROM AN AMATUER: So I went through it on Photoshop, and it looks like they reassembled stats of the OA and did a little bit of cosmetic work to get them to work with a quick plaid treatment to one side of the suit. Would have been a bit of work to do, but the dimensions (with a little warping here and there) are so spot-on that the published version does not look to be light-boxed or re-done. While there might be a 97% stat out there, I think this is the real OA that leads to the corrected stat cover. That being said, you have a Two-Face image where the clean side of the room is on the scar-side of his face, and the dirty side is on the clean side of his face and editorial hated it so much they made a production guy bust out his master-class Exacto knife skills...can I get over that fact if I bid enough to win OR will it haunt me every time I look at it... uggh. Don't know.

    If someone has a different opinion, I'd love to know about it. Again...amateur examination knowing that some of you are much better at this kind of thing.

    Bob

    Heritage changed their description:

    "...while the published cover shows some differences, we believe this detailed piece was used, supplemented by stats created in production to create the printing plate.

    To elaborate about the changes in the original art being offered and the final version of the published comic book, comparing the images of Batman and Two-Face on the original art to the published cover, they line up perfectly. For the cover, the pattern on Two-Face's suit was probably changed for editorial consistency or to make it easier to draw on the interior pages. On the cover, background elements appear to have been switched/photoshopped in production, but again align perfectly when mirrored."

    July Heritage Auction Sorta Shaping Up!

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob

    And the Batman #313 cover....Heritage says "This is possibly an alternate cover that was either reconfigured in production or rejected in order to maintain editorial consistency with the characters." 

    OK, so does anyone know if this is a rejected cover that had to be redrawn completely and there a clean version of this in the wild? Or did the background get flipped in production with a very good Exacto + a new suit pattern was applied?  I haven't taken the time yet to overlay them in Photoshop and see how the lines look in obverse. 

    UPDATE FROM AN AMATUER: So I went through it on Photoshop, and it looks like they reassembled stats of the OA and did a little bit of cosmetic work to get them to work with a quick plaid treatment to one side of the suit. Would have been a bit of work to do, but the dimensions (with a little warping here and there) are so spot-on that the published version does not look to be light-boxed or re-done. While there might be a 97% stat out there, I think this is the real OA that leads to the corrected stat cover. That being said, you have a Two-Face image where the clean side of the room is on the scar-side of his face, and the dirty side is on the clean side of his face and editorial hated it so much they made a production guy bust out his master-class Exacto knife skills...can I get over that fact if I bid enough to win OR will it haunt me every time I look at it... uggh. Don't know.

    If someone has a different opinion, I'd love to know about it. Again...amateur examination knowing that some of you are much better at this kind of thing.

    Bob

    Covid19-The death of cash deals?

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob

    Let's ignore taxes.

    For me, the real benefit of the cash deal is also peace of mind that a) for the buyer, that the art is in your hand after inspecting it and b) for the seller, that the check isn't going to bounce/a bogus fraud claim is going to get filed on PayPal. At today's prices for some A and A+ pieces, people will continue to do cash deals. Collectors in NYC will still do it. But maybe you don't fly across the country to do it where you might have considered a couple hundred dollar flight cost as part of the economics of the deal. 

    May Heritage Auction Really Shaping Up!

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted

    On 3/4/2020 at 11:43 AM, Sideshow Bob said:

    The Zeck SSM #131 cover sold for $33k at HA in Nov 2017. This is obviously a better cover, but is it double? I had it pegged around $40k - 50k. Given that SSM #132 sat at $60k for that long, between the two seems about right. But we've seen plenty of pieces languish on a dealer site only to get wrapped up higher with bidders caught up in auction fever. 

    Hammer at $43k, with BP $51,600. 

    Congrats to the new owner! 

    May Heritage Auction Really Shaping Up!

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted

    2 hours ago, Bronty said:

    I dunno.   I would guess they are thinking some percentage of their consignor pool May be hard up for cash right now 

    That is how a successful auction house is run. Strike while the iron is hot when people want to buy, and strike while the iron is hot when people need to sell. They always get paid, either way and every time.

    Great chapter in Freakonomics that specifically addresses this topic for real estate brokers encouraging you to take that offer that's on the table, and it isn't because it's in your best interest.

    May Heritage Auction Really Shaping Up!

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted

    47 minutes ago, Bronty said:

    Doesn't seem that horrible to me, so I'll say a bit over.   (I'm very biased though having it been, as I say, a childhood purchase).     I suspect the fact its not the flagship title drags it down a bit.

    The Zeck SSM #131 cover sold for $33k at HA in Nov 2017. This is obviously a better cover, but is it double? I had it pegged around $40k - 50k. Given that SSM #132 sat at $60k for that long, between the two seems about right. But we've seen plenty of pieces languish on a dealer site only to get wrapped up higher with bidders caught up in auction fever. 

    Art Day - Kyle Hotz Batman and the Spectre

    in Original Comic Art

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob

    I reached to him when that issue came out, and [edit] he said doing Batman was the reason he had gotten into comics in the first place [edit] and he didn't want to consider selling. The excitement was just too much and separating from the work too soon was not in the cards. Looks like I should have reached out a little later, as it seems he changed his mind! They are all tremendous. Many kudos on keeping the issue together...every page is wonderful.

    Bob

    WTB: YTLM and Locke & Key (+ others)

    in Original Comic Art Marketplace

    Posted · Edited by Sideshow Bob

    Imagine Santa asks, "This year, you been a good socially-adjusted man-child who still reads comic books...what OA would you want for Christmas?"

    So here's that list!!!

    1) Still on the hunt for Y:The Last Man interior pages (from the first 12 issues only).

    2) Any interiors or covers from Locke & Key. If you have any L&K art by Gabe Rodriguez, don't hesitate to reach out and receive a very healthy offer!

    3) Also: Looking for any pages from Detective #526 or Batman #366, both of which are Newton/Alcala on pencils/inks. 

    4) Also, also: Jerry Bingham pages from Batman: Son of the Demon

    5) Needle in haystack: Looking for the six covers from IDW's Wild Blue Yonder, by Zach Howard. Bought directly from the artist, and poof, just like Keyser Soze, they're gone. 

    Happy holidays!

    Bob