TheMightyJohn

This is getting to be ridiculous and offensive. I am tired of the same click on these boards ganging up and trashing new members when one of them gets upset. THIS HAS TO STOP!!! Everyone of these post are offensive and should be blocked and their posters hit with strikes. Why s nothing being done? It's no wonder the CGC boards have such a bad reputation among the collecting community.

12/20/13 PROBATION LIST UPDATE [/size] Menace added to Hall of Shame List 12/21/2013. THE HALL OF SHAME The following Board Members have been elected by the community to the Probation List's "Hall of Shame" for gross misconduct as members in the Marketplace Forum: Herald2Galactus (Inaugural Member & 1st "Hall of Shame" Member) gilbertotorres (added 11/5/08 - 2nd "Hall of Shame" Member) ComicSupply (added 10/28/08 - 3rd "Hall of Shame" Member) CAP freak (added 5/21/09 - 4th "Hall of Shame" Member) AlleyBat aka BucOne aka WolfHulk aka Roxx Gang aka MarkWeb aka lastyle7 aka royig aka Punkkitty aka bamaboy aka Greenpep (added 5/23/08 - 5th "Hall of Shame" Member) TFL (added 6/2/09 - 6th "Hall of Shame" Member) Dr. Frankenstein aka muscleshark aka WALDO-JOHNSON (added 5/3/10 - 7th "Hall of Shame" Member) TheDanimal (added 8/12/10 - 8th "Hall of Shame" Member) MachineGunned aka William Townsend aka Chester Jordan (added 8/31/10 - 9th "Hall of Shame" Member) Joker-Fish (added 11/3/10 - 10th "Hall of Shame" Member) Gecko157 - ebay ID lanternsector2814 (added 7/12/12 - 11th "Hall of Shame" Member) comicseekers AKA primeinvestibles AKA megacon (added 11/18/12 - 12th "Hall of Shame" Member) smashdash (added 2/5/13 - 13th "Hall of Shame" Member) twen37 aka thocelizabeth aka elizabeth7372013 on ebay aka The House Of Comics.com aka Thomas Neely and/or Elizabeth Neely (added 6/28/13 - 14th "Hall of Shame" Member) - note - this is a different dealer than CGC board member HouseofComics.Com The Silver-Age (added 9/7/13 - 15th "Hall of Shame" member) Red Rocks (added 11/1/13 - 16th "Hall of Shame" Member) solarcadet 1 (added 12/20/13 - 17th "Hall of Shame" Member) Menace (added 12/21/13 - 18th "Hall of Shame" Member) THE PROBATION LIST The following Board Members are currently on "Probation" for failure to complete a Marketplace Forum transaction in good faith after one month's time. Those with an "Off-Board" notation indicate the failed transaction occurred outside of the CGC Message Boards. [*] 50s Horror Buff (added 05/24/12) [*] AshCan Press aka Matthew Rosenberg (added 5/17/13) [*] aaron568 (added 11/6/08) [*] Akiyama (added 02/15/12) [*] Babygorilla (added 2/2/13) [*] BATMANFAN (added 2/9/10) [*] bkwon12 (added 10/08/09) [*] brasseye (added 7/2/09) [*] bronzejunkie (added 3/26/07) [*] Campbelljh3 (added 9/14/12 & 1/4/2013) AKA Soup1998 [*] CarlWeathers75 (added 8/1/13) [*] Chrissr (added 12/22/09) [*] clobberintime (added 11/7/07) [*] comicmankev (added 3/27/07) [*] daken2626 (added 10/14/11) [*] DarkKnight2K4 (added 4/24/08) [*] donavan74 (added 3/27/07) [*] excelsior1986 (added 9/09/12) [*] erbdom (added 12/08/09) [*] ffxmen14 (added 4/12/10) [*] Gaijin2010 (added 9/24/10) [*] Ghastly (added by majority vote 12/3/07) [*] GoodAsh (added 1/10/12) [*] Goosie (added 6/6/12) [*] Hammerhead (voluntarily added 7/27/11) [*] Henchman (added 4/25/08) [*] HGComics (added 10/7/09) [*] htown79 (added 8/4/10) [*] holyghost (added 6/30/11) [*] itsatoy67 (added 9/21/11) [*] Jackstostart (added 7/30/12) [*] JMG (added 12/26/12) off-board Crees Tyler (CAF) [*] Joey21 (added 5/11/12) [*] JohnnyG (added 5/17/13) [*] kevin109 (added 4/19/10) [*] Lighthouse (added 6/13/07) [*] Marc Wolfe (added 9/15/08) [*] Marvelguy34 (added 8/5/11) [*] matewan1990 (added 3/3/08) [*] mikey1215 (added 5/17/13) [*] mishu2nite (added 3/3/10) [*] mongoose01 (added 12/01/13) [*] mrmaha (added 4/7/13) [*] Nascar (added 6/2/07) [*] NEXTLVL (added 10/12/08) [*] panahobit (added 3/8/11) [*] phobalicious aka darkness4life (added 07/19/12) [*] picklepuss (added 11/27/12) [*] pmahoney74 (added 12/22/12) [*] Pook (added 12/01/13) [*] rawisokv (added 04/07/13) [*] rza808 (added 10/18/11) [*] SAGAT (added 4/29/11) - Off Board via eBay - eBay ID = Miffybunny [*] Sid (added 8/8/07) [*] SilverSlinky (added 11/20/09) [*] SIXX_VAN_ROSE (added 11/7/08) [*] SpiderJay300 (added 9/15/07) [*] SuperbeastCraig (added 11/10/2013) [*] Superman20 (added 12/18/07) [*] tangelwood42 (added 11/28/12) [*] Taz007 aka Thesavros aka Rudolph (added 7/15/09) [*] tibex82 (added 8/1/13) [*] Tyson (added 10/7/11) Xalechim [*] vacantpassenger (added 11/11/12) [*] Venom (added 11/06/13) [*] WDMARVELCOMICS aka WalkingDeadComics (added 6/16/12) [*] Webhead1981 (added 12/26/12) [*] wushugushu (added 5/17/13) [*] Xalechim (added 04/24/12) [*] YUJIRO (added 8/30/12) [*] ZoMbiE13 (added 9/21/11)

Voting ended today. Menace is in the HOS.

Agreed, fantastic episode!!!

+1 You forgot to add the Tony Daniel OP to this list as well. Several issues in this one. None of which were on the artist. Then you had the probation thing which they all got deleted because he was posting personal and paypal info on the boards. Mods deleted most of those before the next morning. And the list goes on..... As far as removing him. I did receive my refund. But I do think something else should happen here besides removing him or what is the point? Seems like Menaces problems go a lot further then "Hearsay" For anyone who missed it MENACE is being nominated for the HOS. Vote is on page 1990 http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=7234272&fpart=1990

+1

Since it 14 pages back For anyone who missed it MENACE is being nominated for the HOS. Vote is on page 1990 http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=7234272&fpart=1990

A little surprised by your answer. I thought we were discussing HOS and there needs to be more issues than what has been discussed so far. MightyJohnny kept referring to "the list" of issues. I agree on the PL and I do not see how I am diminishing anything. When someone says he's got issues with delivering items to several people, it doesn't help clarify the scope of people impacted by calling something like the Medina sketch opp a "single" instance. There's something like 10 sketches that have been done, completed, and waiting to be sent to CGC to make it back into the hands of the people who bought and paid for them long long ago. They are ALL impacted, they all have an issue, gripe, and are in need to Menace to get off the pot and do what was promised. Every single person has an individual agreement with Menace. Each one paid, individually, for the service that was promised. Each one of them is owed, individually, the full and complete service they bought and paid for without unreasonable delay. All I meant was, calling the sketch opp. with anywhere from 6-10 people waiting, unreasonably, for the books to get sent to CGC just "one" issue, gives the reader the impression that it's just one small problem. It's more effective, to determine the scope of what needs to be done to help these people to not lump things into a pile if the lumping leads to calling something like the Medina sketch opp. just one issue. It's not your intention to do so, but that's what's coming across by fighting the semantic definition of "issues". That's all I meant. Interesting. In the context of a HOS discussion I think it is very relevant to differentiate. 10 different transactions all with the same undesireable result could be worthy of HOS while this one issue affecting 10 is not. He should be on the PL until he makes it right. There is nothing I have seen posted here to suggest his intention is to rip people off. Not refunding Jdub for 5 months is not ripping him off? That is what got him on the POL not the Medina opp.

How does it not make Menace a thief that he ignored pm's, removed himself from pm's, didn't respond to emails, or facebook messages concerning Jdubs return for 5 months? It was a sub $100 returned in July and he didn't bother to provide a refund until he was finally added to the POL and talk of the HOS last night? I'm sorry but Menace is a thief!

And he already hit the notify moderator button on the poll. I guess he feels we shouldn't follow our own guidelines. Didn't you know he is above the rules??? How else could he still operate as a facilitator for CGC with all of the complaints on him Where is this list of complaints you keep referring to? I see 2 issues. He has had numerous complaints on him brought to Mikes attention of the last year or more. All of this is nothing new with Menace. AKA - you do not know. It's ok not to know. If you have a list please share otherwise hearsay doesn't help. (thumbs u I sense a very personal vibe with your posts. Do you have something personal with Menace? No not hearsey what I know is from my conversations with Mike B a year ago when Menace screwed me. Menace also was added to the probie list last May by me. After a long apology Email from him about his family business blah blah blah. I felt bad and request the mods delete my flamming. I'm sure there are some from the ss room than can recall this and back me. Dscott I am sure remembers he helped with the situation. Ok. So now we're up to 3 issues and the rest as I asked earlier is hearsay. If one of those issues involves up to 10 people not getting their books because of an unreasonable and inexcusable delay on his part. I am reluctant to dismiss it as a single issue. Each of those people has an issue with him, don't they? Otherwise we'd have a precedent, for example, for someone who ran a sales thread and did not deliver to 20 different people that it was just one issue because it was just one thread. +1

And he already hit the notify moderator button on the poll. I guess he feels we shouldn't follow our own guidelines. Didn't you know he is above the rules??? How else could he still operate as a facilitator for CGC with all of the complaints on him Where is this list of complaints you keep referring to? I see 2 issues. He has had numerous complaints on him brought to Mikes attention of the last year or more. All of this is nothing new with Menace. AKA - you do not know. It's ok not to know. If you have a list please share otherwise hearsay doesn't help. (thumbs u I sense a very personal vibe with your posts. Do you have something personal with Menace? No not hearsey what I know is from my conversations with Mike B a year ago when Menace screwed me. Menace also was added to the probie list last May by me. After a long apology Email from him about his family business blah blah blah. I felt bad and request the mods delete my flamming. I'm sure there are some from the ss room than can recall this and back me. Dscott I am sure remembers he helped with the situation. Were you reimbursed any money out of pocket for this transaction? Eventually, so what you are saying is that as long as Menace refunds someone he screwed over then it's OK and he should be allowed to keep doing it? How about in Jdubs case where Menace received the book back in July, he then ignored pm's, emails, and facebook message from Jdub and didn't respond or refund him until the after he was added to the probie thread this week?

And he already hit the notify moderator button on the poll. I guess he feels we shouldn't follow our own guidelines. Didn't you know he is above the rules??? How else could he still operate as a facilitator for CGC with all of the complaints on him Where is this list of complaints you keep referring to? I see 2 issues. He has had numerous complaints on him brought to Mikes attention of the last year or more. All of this is nothing new with Menace. AKA - you do not know. It's ok not to know. If you have a list please share otherwise hearsay doesn't help. (thumbs u I sense a very personal vibe with your posts. Do you have something personal with Menace? No not hearsey what I know is from my conversations with Mike B a year ago when Menace screwed me. Menace also was added to the probie list last May by me. After a long apology Email from him about his family business blah blah blah. I felt bad and request the mods delete my flamming. I'm sure there are some from the ss room than can recall this and back me. Dscott I am sure remembers he helped with the situation.

And he already hit the notify moderator button on the poll. I guess he feels we shouldn't follow our own guidelines. Didn't you know he is above the rules??? How else could he still operate as a facilitator for CGC with all of the complaints on him Where is this list of complaints you keep referring to? I see 2 issues. He has had numerous complaints on him brought to Mikes attention of the last year or more. All of this is nothing new with Menace.

Yeah I will be adding this to every page. For anyone who missed it MENACE is being nominated for the HOS. Vote is on page 1990 http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=7234272&fpart=1990

And he already hit the notify moderator button on the poll. I guess he feels we shouldn't follow our own guidelines. Didn't you know he is above the rules??? How else could he still operate as a facilitator for CGC with all of the complaints on him

For anyone who missed it MENACE is being nominated for the HOS. Vote is on page 1990 http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=7234272&fpart=1990

Well this is an easy vote.

I'm having feelings of deja vu. And he can't see the problem, he told people to e-mail him. Too bad JDub did try e-mailing him. It never ends, does it? Now that he's back and making amends everything is OK right? Until the next time... Or the time after that... Or the next time after that time... Or the following time after the next time after that time... Let's all just vote for HOS and be done with it. The dude had a rep long before this. In all the times he has screwed over buyers he still has yet to learn or improve his dealings. We don;t need people like him on here especially since he is a facilitator and chooses to handle business with us this way.

owes j dub a refund or a replacement book. John paid for a 9.8 and Jake sent a 9.6. John returned the book and Jake said he received the book back but never gave the refund or the replacement. Don't forget that Jake received the book back something like 5 months ago.

I don't have a clue how to male a poll but I can send my experience to whomever makes the poll.

Does it matter who starts the poll?

I think we need to put him on the HOS. As a multiple offender in the rules section 5.b he more than qualifies.

You would think that this might be enough for CGC to cut ties with him. I say he vote to put him on the HOS! Considering how many people he has jerked around I think it is justified! At the very least, a PM to the SS coordinator. Trust me Mike is aware of the problems with Menace but never seems to act on it. I know I called Mike when Menace screwed me last year.

You would think that this might be enough for CGC to cut ties with him. I say he vote to put him on the HOS! Considering how many people he has jerked around I think it is justified!

That may be true and it may be on the artists but this seems to be a constant problem with Menace. Lack of communication, lying about books being completed, missed deadlines. I'm sure many members can back me up here that it is not a new issues with him, nor has he shown any signs of trying to improving it. I know I'm not the only one who will no longer deal with him, I'm sure some others will chime in with similar experiences. I just want to add here that John (J Dub) knows how all of the sketch ops and SS things work. He is my CAW when I am facilitating a show so he knows the ins and outs of the SS world. Jake (menace) is a bad reflection on all facilitators and his track record speaks for itself. Maybe one day someone with some power will take a look at how he operates. Couldn't;t have said it better myself, his reputation and practices hurts all facilitators.