kairos70

6 hours ago, CDaBruce said:

Gotham City Sirens #18 VF/NM  $6

Gotham City Sirens #22 NM-  $7

Gotham City Sirens #18 VF/NM  $6

Gotham City Sirens #22 NM-  $7

Just now, GeeksAreMyPeeps said:

Cable is Nathan Summers, but the characteristics that we recognize as Cable were not present in the depiction of the baby that appeared in Uncanny X-Men 201. Therefore Claremont and Leonardi are not credited as creating Cable (and rightly so)

Of course they wouldn't be because it's not a new character. That was never a part of the original discussion. You went off on a tangent. I didn't imply characters can't have different aliases written by different creative teams. For example, Monica Rambeau has three different aliases and the first appearance of those aliases are desirable to collectors. My point to those discussing Batman #664 is that Ellie is not an alias for Punchline and vice versa. Batman #664 is not the first appearance of Punchline as some were concerned about. Batman #664 features the first appearance of Ellie(a totally unrelated character to Punchline) and Bat Bane.

2 hours ago, GeeksAreMyPeeps said:

No. Nathan Summers first appeared in Uncanny X-Men #201, which was written and drawn by Chris Claremont and Rick Leonardi. But they are not credited with creating Cable.

So Cable is not Nathan Summers?

2 minutes ago, GeeksAreMyPeeps said:

Okay, but Simonson and Liefeld are credited as Cable's creators, even though they did not create baby Nathan Summers. The fully formed character is what's important as far as credit goes. (This is not meant to be an opinion on this specific Batman issue)

You're reaching, Any version of Nathan Summers is still Cable whether baby,teen or adult. Marvel just recently released Kid Cable;still Nathan Summers under a time displaced alias. He's not a totally new character just a different alias. Simonson and Liefeld are still the Creators of Nathan Summers just not all of his aliases. BishopT said Tynion denied Punchline and Ellie are the same character because I'm sure he wouldn't try to take credit for a character nor an alias he didn't create. Two different characters.

3 minutes ago, BishopT said:

Speculation is a young Punchline, but that one app says Tynion denies?

I don’t know what I think. I mean I see it, but is it another Wolverine 80 type of deal? I know there are better examples, but I can’t really think right now lol.
 

 

Tynion would have to deny it since Ellie's creators are Grant Morrison and Andy Kubert. Ellie has green eyes while Punchline has blue eyes. James Tynion,Guillem March and Carlo Pagulayan are credited as Punchline's creators. Two different characters.

52 minutes ago, BishopT said:

Thoughts on Batman 664? 
 

 

An already established character named "Ellie".

1 hour ago, jbud73 said:

Marvel Triple Action 35

9.4

$6

Marvel Triple Action 35

9.4

$6

2 minutes ago, GACollectibles said:

Amazing Spider-Man #315 VF+ $4

 

Take

2 minutes ago, GACollectibles said:

Spawn #253 NM- $8 Copy A
Spawn #253 NM- $8 Copy B

Spawn #253 NM- $8 Copy A

Take

Just now, GACollectibles said:

Spawn #255 NM $10

 

Take

Just now, GACollectibles said:

Spawn #254 NM- $8

Take

27 minutes ago, GACollectibles said:

Spawn #248 NM+ $20 Copy A
Spawn #248 NM- $10 Copy B SOLD!!
Spawn #248 NM- $10 Copy C SOLD!!

A few more to be posted shortly!

Spawn #248 NM+ $20 Copy A

36 minutes ago, GACollectibles said:

Spawn #236 NM-/NM $10

31 minutes ago, GACollectibles said:

Spawn #246 NM $12 Copy B

Spawn #236 NM-/NM $10
Spawn #246 NM $12 Copy B

41 minutes ago, maidenmate91 said:

Your Spawn collection is going to be quite impressive, assuming you have them all still. 

Yeah, it's getting there. Working on #160-#218 and 236-259. Already have #219-235 and 260-306. Just filling in around those numbers

Spawn #239 NM $15 Copy A
Spawn #242 NM- $10
Spawn #251 NM- $5
Spawn #255 NM/NM+ $10

3 hours ago, waaaghboss said:

Ready to argue about some trivial comic book nonesense?

You bet your sweet arse!

"It is the way"

2 minutes ago, Real Frantic One said:

Jungle Action #20
9.2 NM-
$15

Jungle Action #20
9.2 NM-
$15

1 minute ago, CDaBruce said:

Venom: Sign of the Boss #2

Great Venom/Ghost Rider cover

VF/NM $3

 

Venom: Sign of the Boss #2

Great Venom/Ghost Rider cover

VF/NM $3

1 minute ago, dzminn said:

Solar 3 VF+ $10.00 1st Harbinger Foundation; 1st Toyo Harada. Also included is the 3rd part of the "Alpha and Omega," a 10-part origin story of Solar Man of the Atom with --script by Jim Shooter and art by Barry Windsor-Smith and Bob Layton. A must have issue! Dynamite Pre Unity issue.

 

Solar 3 VF+ $10.00 1st Harbinger Foundation; 1st Toyo Harada. 

Just now, CDaBruce said:

Superior Spider-Man #31

Campbell Variant

NM+  $4

 

5 hours ago, Readcomix said:

Marvel Comics Presents #6 copy A&B, 1st appearance of Rein, both NM, your choice $30 each or take the pair for $50.

Marvel Comics Presents #6 copy A&B, 1st appearance of Rein, both NM, your choice $30 each or take the pair for $50.

The Pair for $50

3 minutes ago, CDaBruce said:

X-Men Blue #1

J Scott Campbell Exclusive Variant

NM+  $8

 

X-Men Blue #1

J Scott Campbell Exclusive Variant

NM+  $8

11 minutes ago, CDaBruce said:

Domino #1

Dell'Otto Trade Variant

NM- $9

 

2 minutes ago, CDaBruce said:

Captain America #14 

Origin Winter Soldier 

9.0   $7

Take it

1 minute ago, CDaBruce said:

Thor Annual #11

First Peter Dinklage!  (Eitri the Dwarf)

VF+  $5

 

Thor Annual #11

First Peter Dinklage!  (Eitri the Dwarf)

VF+  $5