WPPJames

$95 + $15 shipping (shipped Priority Mail NOT Media)

Note that is a "sticker residue" on the JD slab cover. It could probably be removed with the proper cleaner? Same with Harley Quinn one. These are on the slabs due to me being an id*ot and not the comics themselves.

OK. So first time seller here. If that's a deal breaker I understand. If you are a long time "respected" forum member I'd probably be willing to send first and have you Paypal me later. We can discuss. Only showing front cover scans as these are not high value books (<$20). Can send other photos on request. Not aware of any noticeable defects on back covers or interiors. But if you discover any after receiving, I'm more than fine with adjusting for that. Will ship all in USPS Priority Flat Rate Box. All comics are currently bagged and boarded. But I reserve the right to remove some boards if needed to fit in the flat rate box.  I'd like to get PM offers for the lot if that's allowed? If not, let me know and I'll try to come up with a price to offer, although I really have no idea.

No expert. But I'd agree the writing on back is negligible. Rip on cover and top staple tear, big subtraction. I'm a bit lower (as usual) at 6.0/6.5.

1 hour ago, Mecha_Fantastic said:

I mean, I know people are stupid. I really do. But wow, we have a contender here. Someone start a gofundme to get this fine specimen neutered, please! 

Sigh. Yea, forcing me to again state, "And of course the seller has a "100% positive feedback" on Ebay. Further validating my opinion that that means practically nothing"

Thanks for the feedback. It's currently up for auction via consignment. They have it listed as 4.0, so you pretty much nailed it. Just curious for feedback as if they had slightly under graded it would be effecting the bid amounts. Really, really wish I could afford to keep this one. I personally think it will be a good investment to whomever buys it. Even though the price has already gone up a lot on it. First silver age Catwoman? Fight with Lois Lane? C'mon 

Apologies if I shouldn't be posting this here? Have about 40 mainly $0.25 and under books I want to sell. None are worth selling individually. Was about to wholesale them to mycomicshop.com, but thought I'd inquire here first. Haven't sold here before, so would anyone be willing to buy from me without having a proven track record? Maybe more so if I allowed a respected buyer / member to receive shipment prior to paying? Just don't want to spend the time of scanning the covers of 40 comics if it's going to be a waste of time. And it kills me to wholesale off stuff for practically nothing if I can get more $$$ and someone else can feel like they can get a good deal buying. A few of the ones I want to sell... And only interested in selling all as a lot. Will ship USPS priority mail medium flat rate box.

And of course the seller has a "100% positive feedback" on Ebay. Further validating my opinion that that means practically nothing. Learned that the hard way. Also, and this will probably off the majority of the people here, but I will not buy from anyone who ships comics USPS media mail. Barely containing myself from going off on a major rant on that subject.

First off, I absolutely love that front cover! And I want to give it an additional +1 grade just for the hilarious ad on the back. But grading this one is tough for me due to the taped spine (and top cover?). Throw out a 2.0 and let others correct me, as I could be significantly off in either direction.

Only have these two photos so realize that makes this trickier to grade, but opinions would still be appreciated.

6.0 to 6.5 my guess. Not only is the front cover pretty awesome, but the ad on the back cover isn't bad either.

No way it's worth it to send it in. Not trying to be insulting, but it would be like buying a $30 saddle for a $5 horse.

Just don't know how much to deduct for the missing pieces on top cover. Especially larger one at spine. Going with a 2.0 I guess. But, again, love the book!

3.0 my best guess.

Love that comic! This one, for me, is a bit tricky. No idea on interior. Cover and/or centerfold fully attached to staples (bottom one in particular)? 1.5/2.0? Leaning more towards G-/G (1.8/2.0).

As usual, I go lower. 3.0 my guess.

4.0 to 4.5. Leaning more towards 4.5. Good Luck!

My guess also a 6.5

15 minutes ago, Karl Liebl said:

Almost certain a press would bump to 8.5!

Agree. And it would certainly be worth the "risk" on a book of that value.

Thanks for the feedback everyone. My estimate was pretty much in line with everyone else's. Sometimes it's not, so always good to get second opinions. Especially on books I'm about to list on Ebay.

Spine roll? Minor flaking on edge of front cover. 8.0?

My guess is 4.0.

edit: sorry, I missed the 3.0 reveal. Major ouch on that one!

Agree with comicginger on similar condition as #2. Sticking with my 4.5 / 5.0 range on this one as well.

I'm thinking a little lower. 4.5 / 5.0 range.

Mine I sent to Lone Star Comics / Mycomicshop.com on consignment. They set the grade as a 5.0. I requested they send in to CGC. Very curious to see how the CGC grade comes back compared to their initial grade. Will post results. If it ever comes back. Going on 10 weeks now.

4 hours ago, comicdonna said:

I agree.  Send it to Joey to be pressed.

Would love to have contact info for a good C&P guy who can/will also facilitate getting it to CGC afterwards. Can you provide?