Yah, I could be misremembering, but while it was iconic (was in the posters in Cap 400) I never remember it being a high price. Then again, I haven't seen an early 90's price guide since the early 90's I remember drooling over Cap 332, which was around $10 at the time, but don't remember much else in the 250-400 range being really a stand out. But again I'm going off of a 10 year olds memory from 25+ years ago. I need to hunt down an old copy of Wizard. Its a fantastic cover, and I've wanted one for a long time, might have to jump on one sooner than later.
The other one I still feel is a bit undervalued is cap 332. Was my biggest key back in the day.