silverage12c

No real flaws that aren't visible in these pics. Staples are secure, centerfold and all wraps attached nicely. Obvious cover creases and spine stresses, and a 1/2" tear near the cca stamp upper-right front cover.
I always tell myself I'm going to sell some of these keys as I find them, and then I get all attached. This one's probably a keeper now. Thanks for looking

I'm jumping on the 1.5 train

Nice book! And damn these squarebounds with the spine issues. I would be taking a soft white eraser to those white cover areas to clean up some of the dirt, for sure
I think the spine split is much less than 1", I think I have this at a 5.5 with a shot at 6.0

Looking 4.0ish to me, I would say? A number of defects here that can't be helped by a C&P, but I hope you'll share pics after that's done

I think the bottom corner (spine side) is blunted and abraded, and will keep this capped at no better than a 9.4 after press. This is most visible looking at the back bottom-right corner. I may be wrong, but I don't see it reaching 9.6 due that corner blunting. If you press, be careful of the slight front cover overhang

7.0 with potential to reach 8.5 after C&P

On 3/22/2022 at 8:36 PM, PINWHEEL said:

I'm with the majority here, looks like a strong 7.5

I'm on board with this, at a 7.5 ... nice book

2.0, and holding my breath the cover doesn't fall off ;)

Wish my copy were in this condition. (It's a beater/reader). I think the small piece out, and the tear at bottom staple, will cap this at a 6.0, even after a press. Just my 2 cents

Nice book   Those 2 top corners are the only real issues I see. I'm gonna say 7.5, with that small piece out upper-right back cover and the corner blunting.

On 3/22/2022 at 2:58 PM, Funnybooks said:

are you having the book pressed?

 

Actually, these pics are after my own gentle press. I opted not to do more than a simple full-cover (front and back) press job on it. I didn't think that attacking the spine with a tack iron, or anything like that, was going to be worth the risk. Most of the cover damage is just an accumulation of color-breaking stress lines that are not going to be improved anyway. I also did my own gentle dry-clean work on the white areas front and back, to eliminate most of the usual dirt and light scuff marks, etc.
I'm sure a pro could accomplish more than my DIY amateur efforts, LOL. But, I think this book has a grade cap due to the color breaks, no matter who works on it?

8.0, as others have opined

Press & Clean was really effective --- very nice!

Lots of spine ticks here. Even though they are tiny, they accumulate to knock this down to a 6.5 IMO

2.0, I think.

These grading posts are fun. But, when the OP posts very good, close-up pics like these, I think the high-quality images tend to exaggerate the flaws. We're seeing zoomed-in paper fibers and every little defect even better than we might with the book in hand. Leads a lot of us to undergrade, maybe.

On 3/22/2022 at 12:48 PM, MrRoboto said:

Unless it is lighting, looks like the bottom right corner area has been subject to fading. Specifically, the buildings like a little lighter than they are supposed to. 
 

If I am wrong, this book is probably 5.5-6.0

I think it must just be the lighting, because I'm not seeing it? FYI, those aren't buildings, it's an interior scene and the bottom right shows brown wooden stairs
I think you, and most others here, are viewing this book about the same as I am, in the 5.0 to 6.0 range. As mentioned, it's en route to Sarasota for walkthrough service, so I'll have it back soon enough. I'm pulling for a 6.0 Universal OW, but not banking on it, LOL.

Thanks all for your feedback, very much appreciated!

I went ahead and sent it in today for Walk Through grading, so I should have it back in a couple weeks. Will come back and share the grade when I know it.

Cheers, and happy hunting for your grails, series, and readers alike

That bit of spine damage in the first pic looks like the only real problem. But, I think that knocks it down to about a 7.5. 
(Larger pics, taken with the comic out of the bag, would be better).

6.5

Nice gloss, lies flat. Obvious issues are the 10 to 12 spine stresses (especially at bottom staple). Tiny diagonal crease lower-right front cover, and a 3/4" printer's crease near the upper-right front cover. Centerfold and all wraps tight and attached.

What do you all think? And, thanks very much for taking a look 

On 8/31/2021 at 3:35 PM, byosti said:

Amazing Spider-Man #361 CGC 9.6

$335

  thanks!

Green Lantern 63 CGC 8.0 $88
 

25% Everything offered in this thread --- Let's see if I can clear a little more space, and get some fun books in your hands

Ghost Rider 30 - 7.0 OW $4
Ghost Rider 19 - 7.0 OW $6
Peter Parker Annual 1 - 8.5 OW $5
Iron Man 178 - 8.0 OW $2
Iron Man 87 - 8.0 OW $7
Luke Cage 7 - 7.0 OW $2
Luke Cage 10 - 4.0 OW $1
Daredevil 119 - 8.0 
Avengers 168 - 8.5 OW $9
Avengers 155 - 6.5 OW $6
Avengers 116 - 6.5 OW $9
GS Man Thing 1 - 5.0 OW 
She Hulk 11 - 8.5 OW $3
Dr Strange 17 - 7.0 OW $3
Strange Tales 140 - 4.0 OW $8
Hulk 204 - 8.5 OW $3
Thor 255 - 7.0 OW $3
Thor 194 - 7.0 OW $6

Fun Lot of 3 Gold Keys:
Flash Gordon #34 6.0
Doctor Solar #29 5.0
Grimm's Ghost Stories #56 6.0
$10  for the lot