• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Maskedvigilante

Member
  • Posts

    331
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Maskedvigilante

  1. On 9/27/2021 at 1:52 AM, Qalyar said:

    For what it's worth... I haven't really kept count of how many books I've had slabbed, either for my personal collection or via my involvement in the business side of the hobby, but it's probably north of five hundred at this point, dating all the way back to the red-label Modern days. In all that time, I've had one-ish* book that had to go back for a label correction, one book that had a hair in the slab, and no books significantly damaged by the grading process.

    A lot of books get slabbed, and relatively few have problems. We see the vast majority of those problems here, so confirmation bias is a legitimate concern. That's not to excuse some of the damage or the label problems (especially the multi-book label swapfests; seriously, people...), but most books are not damaged by CGC's handling and encapsulation. I still think the OP's images are more consistent with reflection from a very bright scanner (look at the difference in color saturation between the scanner image and the unslabbed photograph!) rather than actual damage, but I'd need the book in hand (or other images) to really know for certain.

    * Technically, I've had two mechanical error returns, but the other one involved some debate with CGC over how they were labeling a low-value somewhat obscure book, and ultimately resulted in a change the labeling policy for it; I don't really consider that to be an error per se. The second printing they recently slabbed without notation, that one was on them.

    Well what I see is there are alot of factors involving the slabbing, and I think you're right here.

  2. On 9/27/2021 at 1:52 AM, Qalyar said:

    For what it's worth... I haven't really kept count of how many books I've had slabbed, either for my personal collection or via my involvement in the business side of the hobby, but it's probably north of five hundred at this point, dating all the way back to the red-label Modern days. In all that time, I've had one-ish* book that had to go back for a label correction, one book that had a hair in the slab, and no books significantly damaged by the grading process.

    A lot of books get slabbed, and relatively few have problems. We see the vast majority of those problems here, so confirmation bias is a legitimate concern. That's not to excuse some of the damage or the label problems (especially the multi-book label swapfests; seriously, people...), but most books are not damaged by CGC's handling and encapsulation. I still think the OP's images are more consistent with reflection from a very bright scanner (look at the difference in color saturation between the scanner image and the unslabbed photograph!) rather than actual damage, but I'd need the book in hand (or other images) to really know for certain.

    * Technically, I've had two mechanical error returns, but the other one involved some debate with CGC over how they were labeling a low-value somewhat obscure book, and ultimately resulted in a change the labeling policy for it; I don't really consider that to be an error per se. The second printing they recently slabbed without notation, that one was on them.

    Actually i have recently joined the board after a while and all I'm noticing is lack of quality control maybe it's psychological. Ever since Blackstone acquired cgc, several YouTubers and boardies were posting pictures of books ruined by cgc.

  3. On 9/23/2021 at 7:10 AM, SGS79 said:

    Can someone please tell me if I can bring a comic book at a comic book convention, drop it off at cgc with a signature received at the Comic-Con via witnessed signing event, that I also want cleaned by the third party vendor. Would cgc first give the sign comic book to ccs to clean it and press it before assigning a grade to it?

    Make sure to take pictures before sending it for grading.