AF 15: Qualified vs. Restored vs. Universal

[joe_collector]

Now this creepy auction of a partial copy of AF 15 is over and ended at $1.675.00.

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2189531250&category=32739

 

If anyone has GPAnalysis or keeps track of sales, I'd really like to know how this sale stacked up to CGC copies of AF 15 at:

 

CGC 0.5 Universal (and/or 1.0-1.8)

CGC 6.0 Restored (Slight)

CGC 6.0 Restored (Moderate)

 

Along with any CGC 4.0 to 5.5 Restored copies, as these are more attractive buys than a copy missing 10 full pages.

 

 

[joe_collector]

Come on, several forum members stated interest in how a CGC 6.0 Q affected the price of what is effectively a Poor comic, and someone must have some data.

[DiceX]

Come on, several forum members stated interest in how a CGC 6.0 Q affected the price of what is effectively a Poor comic, and someone must have some data.

 

I have the data.

But I wasn't interested in the thread.

[Warlord]

Come on, several forum members stated interest in how a CGC 6.0 Q affected the price of what is effectively a Poor comic, and someone must have some data.

 

C'mon data-havers! Give!

 

Actually I'd like to see the data on all the 6.0 and below AF15s (restored and unrestored) for some reasonable period of time.

[PovertyRow]

It is my opinion someone has a [!@#%^&^] cover AF15 and will be filling in this one with the pages, or using this cover on their pages.

[greggy]

It is my opinion someone has a [!@#%^&^] cover AF15 and will be filling in this one with the pages, or using this cover on their pages.

[PovertyRow]

It is my opinion someone has a [!@#%^&^] cover AF15 and will be filling in this one with the pages, or using this cover on their pages.

 

Screw thou hippiest!

[greggy]

It is my opinion someone has a [!@#%^&^] cover AF15 and will be filling in this one with the pages, or using this cover on their pages.

 

Screw thou hippiest!

Shaddup oh bitter gramps!

[Bugaboo-migration]

Come on, several forum members stated interest in how a CGC 6.0 Q affected the price of what is effectively a Poor comic, and someone must have some data.

 

I have the data.

But I wasn't interested in the thread.

[PovertyRow]

Shaddup oh bitter gramps!

 

Don't you be getting all uppity on us elderly people!

[Rip]

There you go

 

 

(3.0) (10) $1,818.76 2,670/1,375   Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Jun 2003

(2.5) (2) $1,537.50 1,650/1,425   Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Jun 2003

(2.0) (6) $1,309.85 1,500/1,009   Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Aug 2003

A (2.0) - $1,317.95     - Trimmed Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Jun 2003

(1.8) (2) $1,052.56 1,094/1,011   Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 May 2003

SA (1.8) - $1,125.00     -   Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Jul 2003

(1.5) - $1,050.00     -   Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 May 2003

(1.0) (3) $780.37 800/750

[Warlord]

That's good info, thanks for posting it!!!!

[Verbow]

Looks like restored copies are going for slightly more than the qualified sans-10 pages copy at 6.0:

 

MA (6.0) - $1,801.00 - Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Jun 2003

 

MA (6.0) - $1,854.00 - Trimmed Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Aug 2003

 

MP (6.0) - $2,247.00 - Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Oct 2002

 

A 4.5 restored went for slightly less:

 

A (4.5) - $1,600.00 - Marvel Comics 1 1962 1 Mar 2003

[joe_collector]

Thanks for the numbers, and this makes me feel even more like that Qualified POS went for way more than is logical, unless some insufficiently_thoughtful_person is trying to create a Frankenstein book from old parts.

 

I'd much rather own a CGC 6.0 Restored book (no trimming) with color touch, etc. on it, than some incomplete, half-the-book ripped out, Qualified monstrosity.