Miscut + Old Label = Resubmission?

[R-Man-migration]

I have a Defenders #10 9.2 with WHITE pages and an old label which indicates 'Miscut'. Since it has an old label, would it be a good candidate for rebsubmission?

[TFL-migration]

I would leave well enough alone on a mis-cut book. It has a nice grade now. I wouldn't take the chance if it were my book.

[Timmay]

I have a Defenders #10 9.2 with WHITE pages and an old label which indicates 'Miscut'. Since it has an old label, would it be a good candidate for rebsubmission?

 

resubmission won't fix it

 

even in a new holder it will still be miscut

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

welcome to the boards

[R-Man-migration]

Thanks. I thought that the powers that be might be a little more lenient in their later years towards that type of production defect.

 

Hopefully this isn't a beat-up topic, but what's the scoop on book misalignment in general? I realize that the book that I posted is mis-cut, and obviously skewed in a counter-clockwise direction, but I have several high grade books with that ugly white stripe running down the left hand side. I feel that a properly aligned book is more appealing and so, more desirable.

[CAP Freak]

I have a Defenders #10 9.2 with WHITE pages and an old label which indicates 'Miscut'. Since it has an old label, would it be a good candidate for rebsubmission?

Welcome Welcome.

[bhhooks22]

My belief is that while CGC doesn't really knock it down,.....reality would tell me that it would not be as appealing...ie..marketable to as many people......comprendo ..??

[Timmay]

I realize that the book that I posted is mis-cut, and obviously skewed in a counter-clockwise direction, but I have several high grade books with that ugly white stripe running down the left hand side. I feel that a properly aligned book is more appealing and so, more desirable.

 

Resubmission might garner the same grade minus "miscut" on the label. A reholdering might do the same; worth a call to CGC to find out.

 

Edit: post your books right side up so we don't have to scroll left to right (thumbs u

[divad]

 

Resubmission might garner the same grade minus "miscut" on the label. A reholdering might do the same; worth a call to CGC to find out.

 

Edit: post your books right side up so we don't have to scroll left to right (thumbs u

 

Good advice Tim! Re-sub is probably not going to change the grade, but if reholdered, the "miscut" note will more than likely be dropped.