GA BEST ARTIST SURVIVOR SERIES POLL: RD.9

[TheWatcher]

Well, it seems we had a tie for top position this round. As per the rules of war, if there's a tie both artists go. So we bid a fond farewell to both LB Coe and Walt Kelly. We hardly knew ya. Once again, VOTE OFF YOUR TWO LEAST FAVORITE ARTISTS. Let's spin the wheel and see what happens.

 

 

[TheWatcher]

I started it off with Barks and Schomburg. I gave the nod to Schomburg only because I like Everett's precode work soooo much. Tough call for me, though.

[CAP Freak]

Barks and Frank F.

[goldust40]

Frank F.

 

Blasphemy!

 

Voted for Barks and Everett, but it's getting a little arbitrary re who to choose now.

[Paratrooper]

Eisner and Schomburg.

 

Eisner- cause I'm still pissed about Heath being voted off.

 

Schomburg- for his Mr. Potato Head drawings.

[october]

Frank F.

 

[CAP Freak]

I just like his 70's mags way better.

[Theagenes]

Everett and Schomburg.

 

Jeff

[selegue]

Well, it seems we had a tie for top position this round. As per the rules of war, if there's a tie both artists go. So we bid a fond farewell to both LB Coe and Walt Kelly. .....

 

Waaaahhhhh!!

Sorry to see Kelly go, but I have to admit that I was happy to see him make the top ten.

Wasn't the original plan to bump two in each of these rounds? I don't understand what effect the tie had.

 

Schomburg and Frazetta for me this time.

I've voted for Schomburg in previous rounds. His busy war covers and distorted perspectives aren't my favorite, but seeing some of his later work posted here gave me a twinge of regret.

Frazetta was my first "how can I possibly vote one of these guys off?" vote. He got the boot mainly because his body of Golden Age work is so much less than the competition, even though it's all gorgeous!

 

Fun contest.

 

Jack

headed off to pout about Kelly

 

 

[TheWatcher]

Wasn't the original plan to bump two in each of these rounds? I don't understand what effect the tie had.

 

In a tie both artists go. That's the two. Plus, I wanted to ensure we had a top five

[DrWatson]

I wish I could have voted for the same person twice.

[tth2]

So we bid a fond farewell to both LB Coe

 

This was actually one of the easiest rounds for me. Everett and Schomburg.

[ciorac]

Barks and Fine

[The Black Hand ®]

Everett and Wood.

[MrBedrock]

Barks and Everett.

[Comicdey]

everett and barks again...

[JohnT]

Everett and Schomburg.

 

This poll isn't generating the kind of debate that the Survivor Series did. I guess it's too subjective a topic.

 

 

[Paratrooper]

Heath went away so I really don't care anymore. The only winner I would like to see is Frazetta.

[ciorac]

Sad that Barks has lasted this long. He is a very important creator/writer, but to compare his body of work to some of the others left, and those who have gone before him, in my opinion leaves him wanting.

 

There! Some debate.

[toro]

I just like his 70's mags way better.

 

Same here, so for me Frank has to go!