Eternals # 1

[Old_Pages_Breath-migration]

No color fade on top. Just the scanner.

 

 

 

 

[CAP Freak]

9.2 IMO

[piper]

 

9.0

[joeypost]

9.2 IMO

 

(thumbs u

[TFL-migration]

9.0

[divad]

I can't vote because there aren't enough options. The book has a seriously blunted LLBC and a wavy LEBC, both of which appear to be due to overhang damage. Consequently, I don't think you're looking at 9.X, but rather 8.X

[gernblanston]

Who had the 9.6s? 9.0ish, but agree with Divad you need some more options.

[brasseye]

9.2 IMO

 

Ditto.

[Old_Pages_Breath-migration]

I can't vote because there aren't enough options. The book has a seriously blunted LLBC and a wavy LEBC, both of which appear to be due to overhang damage. Consequently, I don't think you're looking at 9.X, but rather 8.X

 

overhang damage ? nuts. this is a 9.2 book easy.

 

[bronzilla]

9.0 Or better IMO not sure the overhang will ding the book too bad (thumbs u

[bronzilla]

The blunting looks more like a curving which could be straitened, and as for waviness..I dont see it.

Remember the Overhang on the All Star Western 10 we saw that was Slabbed and graded 9.0 or 9.2 as I remember?

This comic looks much nicer I think

[divad]

I can't vote because there aren't enough options. The book has a seriously blunted LLBC and a wavy LEBC, both of which appear to be due to overhang damage. Consequently, I don't think you're looking at 9.X, but rather 8.X

 

overhang damage ? nuts. this is a 9.2 book easy.

 

1st, no one in their right mind would slab an Eternals #1

 

2nd, if you look at the FC scan you can see a 3/32" overhang of the BC

 

3rd, CGC wouldn't slab this book, so save your money . . .

[divad]

See directly above . . .

The blunting looks more like a curving which could be straitened, and as for waviness..I dont see it.

Remember the Overhang on the All Star Western 10 we saw that was Slabbed and graded 9.0 or 9.2 as I remember?

This comic looks much nicer I think

[bronzilla]

Your just grumpy Divad since you changed the hairstyle.

[BlowUpTheMoon]

 

1st, no one in their right mind would slab an Eternals #1

 

(thumbs u

[BlowUpTheMoon]

Your just grumpy Divad

 

(thumbs u

[divad]

Your just grumpy Divad

 

(thumbs u

 

And you're just drunk . . .

[Ze-man]

Nice book , love your name btw.

 

While I think you are fine with the grade choices you listed, next time go ahead and put in a few lower ones so people feel like they at least have the option to grade it as they see fit. The book looks like a solid 9.2. The overhang is minimal, especially for a BA book that is not brittle. The LLBC is just rounded, not blunted.

 

And I for one never like to tell somebody whether they should slab or not slab a particular book.....your book, your money your choice. And unless I missed it where did you say you were going to slab the book?

 

 

 

Ze-

 

 

[Old_Pages_Breath-migration]

thanks, ze-man.