PGM: Probably Trimmed X-men #9

[gnat1000]

Well this is the first of 4 that i'm putting up since I got my scanner working right. I bought this over a year ago and didn't realize it looked trimmed til I got it home. I was definitely a newbie back then. So let me know if you think it's trimmed and what grade you think it is. Thanks!!!

 

 

[Comicdey]

feel free to compare it to this untrimmed version....I'll look at yours once I've got my scans up to compare.

[Comicdey]

I don't think yours is trimmed and I'd give it a 5.5

[gnat1000]

Well here is the one off comicpriceguide.com that I was comparing it too. Looks wider to me.

 

[Comicdey]

yeah, but look at marvel girl.....and compare.

[The Troll King]

Well here is the one off comicpriceguide.com that I was comparing it too. Looks wider to me.

 

 

Comics Price Guide crops all their scans

[143ksk]

5.0 and probably not trimmed

[trmoore54]

I'd go 5.5 and I don't think it's trimmed IMHO...

[He11blazer]

I don't think yours is trimmed and I'd give it a 5.5

 

I agree on both points. F- 5.5, and there is no reason at all to suspect trimming. It's just the cover wrap leaning towards the right. See the white spine?

 

Might even go 6.0.

 

 

[burntboy]

i concur with the 5.0 - 5.5 grades and as for trimming, who knows??

 

but, i'd opine that the right edge doesn't look as razor sharp as most trim jobs, so good luck.........

[djpinkpanther67]

F- possible chance of F