A New Month, A New Poll - PGM Avengers # 1

[burntboy]

here's a decent Midgrade copy of Avengers #1. that's a missing color fleck on the extreme LLC. The top staple is still firmly attached.

what do you think??

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Aces]

Looks like a classic 5.5 near fine to me.

 

Would the 4.0 guys please chime in?

Maybe I'm missing something?

[Comicdey]

I gave it a 5.5 also

[Comicdey]

Back looks pristine, you should have read them from the back to front....think how nice the cover would look then.

[piper]

Looks like a classic 5.5 near fine to me.

 

Would the 4.0 guys please chime in?

Maybe I'm missing something?

 

The spine looks a bit rough for 5.5. 5.0

[trmoore54]

This is one of those books I'm sure it looks 5.5+ in hand...but I think technically and what CGC would give this is a 5.0...SWEETNESS!

[silverage12c]

Y'know, I clicked on "5.0" and voted . . . but looking again, I am leaning higher, maybe a 6.0. Collin is right, beautiful back cover!

[Ze-man]

What do I think?.. I think you actually read this book, a lot! I think that is the most spine breaks I have ever seen on a book of yours Harry.(that I remember anyways)

 

While I am in the 5.0 camp because I just cant get past the spine. Then again it has minimal chipping, and if the BC presents as well in hand I could easily go 5.5

 

That's me officially waffling.

 

But I voted 5.0 based on what I could see.

 

 

 

 

[abracadabra]

5.5.

[divad]

5.5 Near Fine

 

 

[uclapeterg]

4.5. The spine is too rough.