Phantom Stranger 18, 25 and 36

[piper]

Phantom Stranger 18

 

Phantom Stranger 25

 

Phantom Stranger 36

[piper]

I'd love some feedback on the 36, as I think it's an easy 9.6.

[oakman29]

on #36 is there 3 or 4 spine ticks in the palm tree?if so 9.2 if not 9.4/9.6

[oakman29]

#18 7.5

#25 8.0

#36 (see above for opinion)

[Point Five]

#18: 8.5 (top edge, few little nicks)

 

#28: 9.0

 

#36: 9.6

 

Nice lineup!

[piper]

#18: 8.5 (top edge, few little nicks)

 

#28: 9.0

 

#36: 9.6

 

Nice lineup!

 

 

Any more feedback?

[sterlingcomics]

#18: 8.5

 

#28: 8.5 (tear will kill it)

 

#36: 9.2 (multiple cbc spine; rounded lrc)

 

CGC will grade these tough. Nice books but not CGC worthy. With CGC's grading lately the #36 might garner a 9.4, but it is not a slam dunk.