PGM: Walt Disney Comics & Stories 162

[alecholland]

Just having a little trouble determining a grade for this one. White spots at the bottom of the front cover are color flecks not chips. Minor foxing on the back cover visible in the scan. I appreciate any opinions I can get on this one as I don't know how much these two defects (along with a couple other minor ones) affect the grade on an otherwise pretty nice copy.

 

Thanks

 

 

 

 

[dannyboy]

I'd say 8.5...but could be a 9.0 in hand

[CAMERANIAC]

I'd say 8.5...but could be a 9.0 in hand

If that's not writing I see on the front cover, I would have to agree....Nice book!

[thirdgreenham]

7.5 low end, but probably 8.0

 

Andy

[Transplant]

8.0

[slackjawcomics]

8.0 sounds good

[alecholland]

Thanks to everyone for their input. I agree with 8.0. I'd like to say 8.5, but I feel the defects just barely keep it out of that grade.

[Jeffro.]

8.0 sounds reasonable. Nice to see a book like this in the grading forum. :thumbsup:

[TFL-migration]

Looks like there is a bit of writing on the FC. Looks like m, m? too me. Still a nice 8.0 IMHO

[alecholland]

I'm not sure it's writing.

 

In hand, it looks more like what you would see if you were using carbon copy paper. I haven't tried to erase it, but there isn't even an impression in the cover like someone has written on it - more like a transfer or something. It's weird.