PGM Nick Fury #6

[Filter81]

Hey Guys,

 

I need help with one more. Note the very small water mark on the bottom of the back cover.

 

 

[tsarax]

Great looking book! I'd say 9.2

[Filter81]

Good news! Thanks! I wasn't sure how to grade a high grade book with a tiny watermark on the back cover. Any other opinions? Or does 9.2 sound right to everyone?

[bhhooks22]

Good news! Thanks! I wasn't sure how to grade a high grade book with a tiny watermark on the back cover. Any other opinions? Or does 9.2 sound right to everyone?

 

I wouldn't get too exited about a 9.2 . I got SLAMMED by a water mark ! ......................I'm just sayin ............ ....................Bh

[bronzilla]

Good news! Thanks! I wasn't sure how to grade a high grade book with a tiny watermark on the back cover. Any other opinions? Or does 9.2 sound right to everyone?

 

I wouldn't get too exited about a 9.2 . I got SLAMMED by a water mark ! ......................I'm just sayin ............ ....................Bh

I hear that!!! WO water 9.0/9.2 with.....

[Filter81]

Good news! Thanks! I wasn't sure how to grade a high grade book with a tiny watermark on the back cover. Any other opinions? Or does 9.2 sound right to everyone?

 

I wouldn't get too exited about a 9.2 . I got SLAMMED by a water mark ! ......................I'm just sayin ............ ....................Bh

I hear that!!! WO water 9.0/9.2 with.....

 

a Doesn't help

 

This one is actually going up for sale and I have no idea what to call it

[bhhooks22]

Good news! Thanks! I wasn't sure how to grade a high grade book with a tiny watermark on the back cover. Any other opinions? Or does 9.2 sound right to everyone?

 

I wouldn't get too exited about a 9.2 . I got SLAMMED by a water mark ! ......................I'm just sayin ............ ....................Bh

I hear that!!! WO water 9.0/9.2 with.....

 

a Doesn't help

 

This one is actually going up for sale and I have no idea what to call it

 

Well , maybe this would help , seriously , ...CGC makes a much bigger deal of it and knocks it drastically . I would consider not slabbing it , if that was the thinking ?...................Bh

[Filter81]

The book I posted in the other thread I was giving some thought to slabbing. This one I was actually planning to sell as-is. I just don't know what to call it or how to price it

[bhhooks22]

The book I posted in the other thread I was giving some thought to slabbing. This one I was actually planning to sell as-is. I just don't know what to call it or how to price it

 

It's OK ! , ..quit crying about it . It's just that CGC slams water marks more than I think they should !.......Trust me , I'm still crying about a couple of mine ......................BH

[bronzilla]

Good news! Thanks! I wasn't sure how to grade a high grade book with a tiny watermark on the back cover. Any other opinions? Or does 9.2 sound right to everyone?

 

I wouldn't get too exited about a 9.2 . I got SLAMMED by a water mark ! ......................I'm just sayin ............ ....................Bh

I hear that!!! WO water 9.0/9.2 with.....

 

a Doesn't help

 

This one is actually going up for sale and I have no idea what to call it

Call it a nice looking book!

For some a low impact watermark is a killer, for me personally As nice as the rest of the book is That slight blemish is Nothing. I think Bhhooks has it right though CGC WILL KILL THE GRADE!!

List the book with the stain disclosed and see what happens!

Good Luck!!

[Filter81]

The book I posted in the other thread I was giving some thought to slabbing. This one I was actually planning to sell as-is. I just don't know what to call it or how to price it

 

It's OK ! , ..quit crying about it

 

No

 

You're right about watermarks though. I still remember CGC really hammered a few books of mine for the same reason a few years ago!

[Filter81]

Not a bad idea. I think I will list this one w/out a grade to be safe. Thanks!

[TFL-migration]

I'd say something like this. If not for a very tiny water mark on the lower back cover. This book would grade @ 9.2 But since that water mark is there. I will call it one of the best 8.0's a collector will ever see....

[gernblanston]

8.0, maybe 8.5 (thumbs u

[Shadow]

I'd lean towards an 8.5 but the mark is so small and on the back that it might eke out a 9.0.

[moonlite]

I was going with 8.5

[joeypost]

I had a similar King-Size Hulk book with a stain (not water stain) about the same degree of severity. A book most forum members thought was a slam dunk 9.4 came back an 8.5. I would use that as a reference.

[burntboy]

a tough call for sure..........but i'm thinking 8.5 seems like a good guess.........

 

Cool cover....... (thumbs u