PGM: Swamp Thing #1

[Schmakt]

Bought this a few years ago from CrazyEd as "NM-" but I think that mess at the top is definitely keeping it down... so I'm thinking VF?

 

Thoughts, please? Thanks!

 

 

[devilsrain]

I was thinking the same thing, that top looks a little rough. Ill say 7.0 or 7.5. Im usually wrong though.

[joeypost]

The back cover alone keeps this out of NM-. The damage to the top looks like numerous thumb creases.

 

I would agree with a 7.0 here. I don't see this as NM-.

[mschmidt]

Looks like a pretty solid VF - I'd say 8.0

[Schmakt]

*sigh*

 

thank ya'll.

[Cimm]

7.5, man... without that reader's creasing at the top, it would've been a 8.5 (slight foxing and a printing crease on the back)...

[Limited66]

7.5

[TFL-migration]

7.0

[alecholland]

One of my personal favorites (note my forum ID).

 

I would say it's in the 7.0/7.5 range. The creasing at the top really brings the grade down on an otherwise nice copy. If you were planning on selling it, I'd go with the lower grade estimate of 7.0 to be safe.

[ROBTOTHEC]

ONE of the first 10 comics I ever purchased! Looks 7.5!

Mine is a 2.5 as I read the hell out of it. I don't care though

because I took it to a show and WRIGHTSON signed it right

across the cover!

By the way!! Crazy Ed overgrades in my opinion!! You would

think with the thousands of CGC books he buys we MUST know

better than to call that a NM-?

[escape21]

7.5