March Madness Grading Tournament- Round of '64'

[Old Fashion PB and J]

Warlock #12 CGC 9.8

 

Guess that wasn't a stain . . .

I guess not.

What you poking at? I bet I got more points than you.

Just have to brag huh. What were your grades ?

[canickus]

Are you kidding me? Tied at 70-70? That is just wrong....

 

Turning grade in now

[comicdonna]

Warlock #12 CGC 9.8

 

Guess that wasn't a stain . . .

I guess not.

What you poking at? I bet I got more points than you.

Just have to brag huh. What were your grades ?

[Old Fashion PB and J]

Warlock #12 CGC 9.8

 

Guess that wasn't a stain . . .

I guess not.

What you poking at? I bet I got more points than you.

Just have to brag huh. What were your grades ?

[CAP Freak]

Are you kidding me? Tied at 70-70? That is just wrong....

 

I know! Can't either of you guys play defense?

[TVanderZwaag]

Yikes, I under-graded hard....Hope I made it to the next round

[Mr.Silvestri]

I have 65 points is that good enough to move on ....

[Aces]

The final grades are in and here are the grades:

 

Amazing Spider-Man #128 CGC 9.2

Avengers #96 CGC 8.5

Tales To Astonish #89 CGC 7.0

Warlock #12 CGC 9.8

 

It looks like we have one overtime game. I will be double checking the scores and I'll have them posted in a couple hours along with full scans of the books.

 

Didn't send grades but I would have guessed:

 

9.2

8.0

8.0

9.8

[trmoore54]

Warlock #12 CGC 9.8

 

Guess that wasn't a stain . . .

I guess not.

 

Likewise on the back of Avengers 96...

 

I hammered the Avengers for the back cover...all the way to No-Point-Ville on that one...

[trmoore54]

Canickus and SNiPER are having a shootout! The game is tied 70-70 at the end of regulation.

 

I will need a grade on the overtime book PM'd to me from both players.

 

Hurry up guys...the suspense is killing me...

[Nostalgic Attic]

 

 

 

[Nostalgic Attic]

Now for the Scores:

 

 

MrSilvestri- 65

Xsmanx- 55

 

Benchwarmer- 45

Jazzman- 32

 

Canickus- 70 OT

SNiPER- 70

 

trmoore54- 40

Whisp- 22

 

DJPinkpanther- 40

General Zod- 50

 

Dollarbill-45

AJD- 29

 

Comicdonna- 52

thirdgreenham- 70

 

The Resurrection- 45

Cimm- 37

 

TVanderZwaag- 22

JohnT- 40

 

 

[s-man]

5th best score and am out!

 

 

Ok...am fine now! Good luck everybody! (thumbs u

[trmoore54]

Now for the Scores:

 

 

MrSilvestri- 65

Xsmanx- 55

 

Benchwarmer- 45

Jazzman- 32

 

Canickus- 70 OT

SNiPER- 70

 

trmoore54- 40

Whisp- 22

 

DJPinkpanther- 40

General Zod- 50

 

Dollarbill-45

AJD- 29

 

Comicdonna- 52

thirdgreenham- 70

 

The Resurrection- 45

Cimm- 37

 

TVanderZwaag- 22

JohnT- 40

 

 

Cool John...we're the lowest scores to move forward! Savin' our A-game for the Final 4!

[trmoore54]

See if I have this right... the max score you could get, assuming you have 4 "spot on" grades, is 95?

 

20 points for each "spot on" grade = 80

5 bonus points for the second spot on grade

10 bonus points for the third spot on grade

 

TOTAL of 95

 

Do you not get a bonus for the 4th spot on grade?

 

You have it right. No Bonus for the 4th spot on because the Tournament Committee may DQ you for running up the score.

 

TRMoore54 holds the tournament record with 90 points in a regulation ballgame.

 

Guess im out then. lame. well have fun with your contest.

 

 

pfff I thought I lost already which is quite possible because my grading sucks and that was who I was paired agasint. I was like 90 points oh gee along with some paranoid ramblings .

 

Now you're out...

[Nostalgic Attic]

Prize List Update:

 

1. Mystery Prize. (You must be attending San Diego Con, Chicago or Philly Wizard this year to pick this prize)- $50 value

2. Iron Man 99 CGC 9.6

3. X-Men 126 CGC 9.2

4. X-Men 278 CGC 9.6

5. The Shadow #1 (11/73) CGC 7.5 White (Donated by Divad)

6. The Crow #1 NM- (Not First Print)

7. (All donated by skao)

• ASM #362 CGC 9.6 White Pages
  
• Amazing Spider-man (20 notecards and envelopes)
  
• Alex Ross DC Superheroes Art (30 postcards)
  
• Mystery Freebies

 

8. Watchmen #1-4. 1 VF, 2 CGC 9.4, 3 NM-, 4 NM-

9. Your Choice: Conan T-Shirt or Chain Saw Massacre T-Shirt for you horror fans. Shipped anywhere in the world from Germany. (Donated by Hesdeadjim)

10. Marvel Team Up 58 CGC 9.6.

 

 

Keep those prizes coming, it would be great to get to 16. Thanks to all who have donated so far.

 

11. Spirit #2 (Harvey Publ. 3/67) CGC 7.5 COW

 

[SNiPER]

Canickus and SNiPER are having a shootout! The game is tied 70-70 at the end of regulation.

 

I will need a grade on the overtime book PM'd to me from both players.

 

I'm on the road and just had a chance to check my score, not sure what to do now with the OT? This is my first time.

[General Zod]

I could've lost my round due to grading like in Nik's contest. His books got the "Nik bump", so I'm not going to make that mistake again. Now I have to play against the #1 seed out of the tough SW.

 

Apologies to Djpinkpanther... you had one of the tougher losses in the opening round.

 

Canickus and SNiPER are having a shootout! The game is tied 70-70 at the end of regulation.

 

I will need a grade on the overtime book PM'd to me from both players.

 

I'm on the road and just had a chance to check my score, not sure what to do now with the OT? This is my first time.

 

You're supposed to PM your grade on this book:

 

OVERTIME

 

Amazing Spider-Man #158

 

 

 

 

[AJD]

Bye everybody!

[He11blazer]

Now for the Scores:

 

 

MrSilvestri- 65

Xsmanx- 55

 

Benchwarmer- 45

Jazzman- 32

 

Canickus- 70 OT

SNiPER- 70

 

trmoore54- 40

Whisp- 22

 

DJPinkpanther- 40

General Zod- 50

 

Dollarbill-45

AJD- 29

 

Comicdonna- 52

thirdgreenham- 70

 

The Resurrection- 45

Cimm- 37

 

TVanderZwaag- 22

JohnT- 40

 

 

 

This game is getting exciting already! Sorry to see you out comicdonna - I was hoping for a face-off between the Action #1 wrap owners! Now I'd better get to studying thirdgreenham's form...