Sgt Fury #28

[Kramerica]

Beautiful book - structurally a 9.0 but the sunshadow detracts. The question is how much? Thoughts?

 

[rjpb]

I'd say that's more of a tanning halo than sun shadow.

 

I've seen CGC be fairly generous with white cover books that show obvious edge tanning, but personally I'd have trouble going better than 8.0.

[cpannell]

Somewhere between 7.0 and 7.5. There's discoloring on all the edges, front and back.

[Limited66]

7.5/8.0

[BillS25]

I'd go 8.0. The halo effect is actually very attractive on this book but if there's any semblance of brittleness in the tanned edges I'd drop it down... a lot.

[Boozad]

I'd be leaning towards a 7.5.

[Kramerica]

I'd go 8.0. The halo effect is actually very attractive on this book but if there's any semblance of brittleness in the tanned edges I'd drop it down... a lot.

 

Actually, no brittleness at all. The edges are nice as is the gloss and colors. I'd been leaning towards 8.0 myself but at the same time a lot of people have also gone 7.5...

[BillS25]

I'd go 8.0. The halo effect is actually very attractive on this book but if there's any semblance of brittleness in the tanned edges I'd drop it down... a lot.

 

Actually, no brittleness at all. The edges are nice as is the gloss and colors. I'd been leaning towards 8.0 myself but at the same time a lot of people have also gone 7.5...

 

No one will ever fault you for being conservative in a grade!