P"R"GM FF 4

[SilverRich]

 

This book looks better in hand than the scan shows, and I'm seeking some thoughts regarding a possible re-sub. I don't have a BC scan, but there aren't any major defects there that I can see. I think that this book should be at least 8.5 and maybe even 9.0, if my stars are aligned right that day.

 

Also, the grader notes would still be attainable, correct?

 

Much thanks in advance. (thumbs u

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thoughts anyone? Is it just me over-loving my book?

[oakman29]

beautiful comic! I think 8.5 can be attainable,but is it worth it to resub for a .5 grade difference?

[djpinkpanther67]

beautiful comic! I think 8.5 can be attainable,but is it worth it to resub for a .5 grade difference?

It would be a value increase of anywhere from $700-1200

 

So yes it would be worth it

[TFL-migration]

8.5 IMHO So Yes, I would re consider re subbing this book. 9.0 is a bit high for this book. But it wouldn't surprise me all that much either.. Very Nice Book.. (thumbs u

[trmoore54]

WOW...nice 8.0! As far as I know they should still have the grader's notes, which would presumably tell you if there was something going on inside the book...hard to see why it couldn't grade out at 8.5 but also hard for us to pick up the fine points in a scan(s)...

 

[Boozad]

Hard to tell through a slab but looking at the corners and the area by the bottom staple I'd be happy with an 8.0

[Comicdey]

very possibly worth it if you plan on selling it.

[supapimp]

is that a LRC color breaking crease? you might want to get it pressed.

[nik]

is that a LRC color breaking crease? you might want to get it pressed.

 

Saw that also. Color breaking crease, so I don't believe pressing will help it.

[supapimp]

is that a LRC color breaking crease? you might want to get it pressed.

 

Saw that also. Color breaking crease, so I don't believe pressing will help it.

 

no it might, i've seen CGC 9.0's & 8.5's with that LRC color breaking crease. pressing might make the rest of the overall structure of the book better.

[Tomega]

Staples might be the deciding factor. Are they rusted at all?

[Limited66]

What is going on with that lower staple

[marvelcollector]

Did you get the grader's notes?

 

Looks like they might have got it right...corners are a bit soft.

Could get an 8.5 on another day maybe....

[Aces]

Staples might be the deciding factor. Are they rusted at all?

 

They look dark but it could be scanner shadows.

 

If they are clean I think a new label might sport an 8.5

[Old Fashion PB and J]

Whats going on in the middle of the binding side? Looks like maybe a chip hanging on ? Middle of the book

[SilverRich]

Thanks for the response, guys. The staples are totally rust-free, but the lower is a tad indented (not detached) with a minute bit of spine fraying around it. The LRC bend is barely noticeable and doesn't break color all the way through.

 

I'm going to call for the notes, and that will make me determine whether to re-submit. Considering the old label, I may at least get a PQ bump out of it.

 

Thanks again for your thoughts.

 

Rich