Question for everbody who has seen the Wolverine Movie

[Mr Mylar]

I would put the movie between incredible hulk and iron man. x-men 2 is still the best x-men movie.

 

 

X-Men 2 =

 

X-Men 3 =

 

Wolverine Origins=

 

X-men 3?

?

 

I loved X-Men 3. It was better than FF 1 and 2, Ghost Rider, Daredevil, the first Hulk a few years back. Great movie IMHO.

 

It was better than those you listed , but not X-Men 2

also DD Directors cut brought it out of the crap level for me.

 

Never saw the directors' cut. I'll check it out. (thumbs u

[Fireboy]

it was great, except for Dud-pool.

[joe_collector]

I would put the movie between incredible hulk and iron man. x-men 2 is still the best x-men movie.

 

Strangest statement ever - it's the Grand Canyon of quality between IH and IM, and X2 sucked monkey balls.

[joe_collector]

I loved X-Men 3. It was better than FF 1 and 2, Ghost Rider, Daredevil, the first Hulk a few years back. Great movie IMHO.

 

X3 is a very good action movie and the only reason it got hammered on nerd forums like this is because fanboys simply can't watch a movie without worrying about funny book continuity. It's also got more "movie moments" than X1 and X2 combined and actually had a story and plot, albeit a bit too much at times.

 

I also believe most haven't seen X2 in a very long time, as this storyless mess is quite embarrassing, as are Wolverine's (cough) fighting abilities.

[Mr Mylar]

I loved X-Men 3. It was better than FF 1 and 2, Ghost Rider, Daredevil, the first Hulk a few years back. Great movie IMHO.

 

X3 is a very good action movie and the only reason it got hammered on nerd forums like this is because fanboys simply can't watch a movie without worrying about funny book continuity. It's also got more "movie moments" than X1 and X2 combined and actually had a story and plot, albeit a bit too much at times.

 

I also believe most haven't seen X2 in a very long time, as this storyless mess is quite embarrassing, as are Wolverine's (cough) fighting abilities.

 

Regarding X3, I really enjoyed seeing Dark Phoenix, Beast, and the Morlocks all in one film. It was like a childhood dream becoming reality.

[MagnetoWasRight]

I'd have to go Ironman, the new Hulk, X-2, The Punisher with Thomas Jane, X-3, Wolverine...with Ironman above and beyond all the rest. Its the best Marvel movie ever made, IMHO...

[joe_collector]

I liked it because a) it had a story and real plot and b) the action scenes were very well done.

 

Go watch X2 and then write a synopsis of the story... umm, Nightcrawler has a kewl bit at the start, Wolverine is sitting in the snow, then the X-Men have to fight lots of people, Magneto escapes, Storm flies the plane, more fights, We meet Bobby's family where were get the whole "gay is like being a mutant" deal pounded in and Wolverine gets shot in the head, Wolverine swings his claws at Lady D like an uncoordinated maroon, somehow a dam breaks and Phoenix dies... and no one searches for her body in the lake.

 

There is no real plot that ties the movie together, stuff just happens for 2 hours, kinda like a Star Wars prequel.

[joe_collector]

I'd have to go Ironman, the new Hulk, X-2, The Punisher with Thomas Jane, X-3, Wolverine...with Ironman above and beyond all the rest. Its the best Marvel movie ever made, IMHO...

 

Other than Spider-man.

 

The thing that really took away from Iron Man was the lame final "battle", where it looked the CGI team ran out of money so there was no budget for a big standoff.

[Mr Mylar]

I liked it because a) it had a story and real plot and b) the action scenes were very well done.

 

Go watch X2 and then write a synopsis of the story... umm, Nightcrawler has a kewl bit at the start, Wolverine is sitting in the snow, then the X-Men have to fight lots of people, Magneto escapes, Storm flies the plane, more fights, We meet Bobby's family where were get the whole "gay is like being a mutant" deal pounded in and Wolverine gets shot in the head, Wolverine swings his claws at Lady D like an uncoordinated maroon, somehow a dam breaks and Phoenix dies... and no one searches for her body in the lake.

 

There is no real plot that ties the movie together, stuff just happens for 2 hours, kinda like a Star Wars prequel.

 

Well said. (thumbs u

[Black Lantern]

I would put the movie between incredible hulk and iron man. x-men 2 is still the best x-men movie.

 

Strangest statement ever - it's the Grand Canyon of quality between IH and IM, and X2 sucked monkey balls.

 

How can a personal opinion be a strange statement? You liked X3 better than X2 and for me it's the other way around. But I would never say that your taste in movies is strange. I really don't know for what such postings are good for...

 

And yes, there is the Grand Canyon between IH and IM, I haven't said anything else. I meant Wolverine ist better than IH but not better than IM. I know, I should have said that IH was stood at the bottom of the list and IM on top of the list.

[awe4one]

I loved X-Men 3. It was better than FF 1 and 2, Ghost Rider, Daredevil, the first Hulk a few years back. Great movie IMHO.

 

X3 is a very good action movie and the only reason it got hammered on nerd forums like this is because fanboys simply can't watch a movie without worrying about funny book continuity. It's also got more "movie moments" than X1 and X2 combined and actually had a story and plot, albeit a bit too much at times.

 

(thumbs u Very entertaining movie...

 

Jim

[MagnetoWasRight]

I'd have to go Ironman, the new Hulk, X-2, The Punisher with Thomas Jane, X-3, Wolverine...with Ironman above and beyond all the rest. Its the best Marvel movie ever made, IMHO...

 

Other than Spider-man.

 

The thing that really took away from Iron Man was the lame final "battle", where it looked the CGI team ran out of money so there was no budget for a big standoff.

 

Yeah, gotta agree there...the final "battle" did leave something to be desired...

[joe_collector]

And yes, there is the Grand Canyon between IH and IM, I haven't said anything else. I meant Wolverine ist better than IH but not better than IM.

 

That's the point of my comment, it really tells us little - like me saying that a new movie I saw is between The Godfather and Catwoman in terms of quality.

[Black Lantern]

And yes, there is the Grand Canyon between IH and IM, I haven't said anything else. I meant Wolverine ist better than IH but not better than IM.

 

That's the point of my comment, it really tells us little - like me saying that a new movie I saw is between The Godfather and Catwoman in terms of quality.

 

Yes, sorry for that. Sometimes it's not easy as a non-native speaker to write down exactly the same what I really want to say.

[husslord26-migration]

I will be there Friday, I think I am the only one who really didn't care for Punisher (Thomas Jane) Why doesn't "War Zone" get any love? As for X-Men...3 was entertaining, cheesey, just like "War Zone" but I like the non stop blood and violence, however X3 was good, It just seemed that guy (Rush Hour) guy director wanted this to be the LAST X-Men movie....I would love to see more and more X-men and New Mutants....least they killed Cyclops!

 

BTW Thanks to everyone for the warm welcome on this forum!!!

[Mr Mylar]

I will be there Friday, I think I am the only one who really didn't care for Punisher (Thomas Jane) Why doesn't "War Zone" get any love? As for X-Men...3 was entertaining, cheesey, just like "War Zone" but I like the non stop blood and violence, however X3 was good, It just seemed that guy (Rush Hour) guy director wanted this to be the LAST X-Men movie....I would love to see more and more X-men and New Mutants....least they killed Cyclops!

 

BTW Thanks to everyone for the warm welcome on this forum!!!

 

WTTB!

 

They never found Cyclops' body. I don't think he's dead

[Bosco685]

It is a shame that Marvel and DC both allow some of their flagship characters to have movies which leave a bad taste in a fan's mouth, while also turning off new fans because the films are so bad.

 

The only reason I bought the first Hulk movie double-disc edition was because Wal-Mart was having a $1.89 sale on select movies for Christmas. If anything, on a very rainy day when I need a half-attention filler while doing work, I can pop it in.

 

I'm one of the oddballs though that liked the Daredevil Director's Cut and Elektra only because they were so Miller story-influenced. X-Men 2 and Spider-Man 2 are still way up there as setting a standard.

 

Glad to hear someone say the selection of Liev Schreiber as Sabertooth was a good move, as I was kind of bummed out that Tyler Mane didn't make it into the movie after what I thought was a great raw version of a killer villain.

[joe_collector]

Yes, sorry for that. Sometimes it's not easy as a non-native speaker to write down exactly the same what I really want to say.

 

And that's why I tend to stay away from French forums.

[Bosco685]

Yes, sorry for that. Sometimes it's not easy as a non-native speaker to write down exactly the same what I really want to say.

 

And that's why I tend to stay away from French forums.

Vince, you are such a sometimes, but too funny most times.

[goldust40]

Yes, sorry for that. Sometimes it's not easy as a non-native speaker to write down exactly the same what I really want to say.

 

And that's why I tend to stay away from French forums.

 

Give the man a break, JC!! At least he's trying.