Grade my Marvel Spot 5/Batman 200

[Rocketeer]

For your consideration.....

 

 

 

[murph0]

That MS 5 looks in line at about 9.2 for CGC. It would be a 9.4 but I think they'd downgrade due to the scuffing.

 

Brian

[supapimp]

i don't know about a 9.2, i see a stain on the back cover, and i'm not talking about the stamp.

[murph0]

You'd be surprised what they grade these MS 5's. Myself, I'd grade this about a VF+. I really don't know why, but out of 12 CGC graded copies of this book. They're all really soft.

 

Brian

[Rocketeer]

You mean by the word year?...didn't notice it before...might be....got it packed up now, don't really want to open it back up...I'll be happy with a 9.0 anyhow...

[sterlingcomics]

My "un"professional opinion: 8.5 to 9.0 for both.

My main concerns are the back covers...

 

Good luck.

[joe_collector]

i don't know about a 9.2, i see a stain on the back cover, and i'm not talking about the stamp.

 

Am I the only one seeing a sun shadow on the back cover of MS #5?

[uclapeterg]

MS: 8.5

 

Superman: 9.0

[sfilosa]

I think we all see it.

 

The question is does CGC downgrade for it?