X-men # 94 - Help me grade

[WilQuon-migration]

What do you guys think?

 

Linky to X-men #94

 

 

Thanks,

 

WQ

[maggy]

looks like a nice book, I give it a 8.5- 9.0

[Aces]

Nice book!

 

The bottom spine corner does have some small damage, but it might still pull a 9.4!

 

Check the attachment for a scan where you can see the whole book at once for QP inseption.

 

[burntboy]

hi wilquon!!! i'm guessing this isn't the #94 that you got (err, almost got) from comix32 last year?!

 

methinks it's a beauty!! the trouble with scans that big is that there's nothing that'll go unnoticed.

 

i'm thinking 9.2 due to the little stuff on the ulc and llc, the upper staple stress, and some rub or whatever around the urc. this would assume that the back and interior are super. hope it graded that high for you and you were happy........

[WilQuon-migration]

Nice book!

 

The bottom spine corner does have some small damage, but it might still pull a 9.4!

 

Check the attachment for a scan where you can see the whole book at once for QP inseption.

 

 

What do you mean?

[Rocketeer]

It is a sweet book ,..but like someone said a scan that big over-emphasis's every little speck...I'd guess at a 9.2 though....

[Mr. Zipper]

Gorgeous book. The only real flaw I see is the scuff above the CCA box.

 

I vote 9.2 give or take .2

 

Congrats on a winner!

[WilQuon-migration]

hi wilquon!!! i'm guessing this isn't the #94 that you got (err, almost got) from comix32 last year?!

 

methinks it's a beauty!! the trouble with scans that big is that there's nothing that'll go unnoticed.

 

i'm thinking 9.2 due to the little stuff on the ulc and llc, the upper staple stress, and some rub or whatever around the urc. this would assume that the back and interior are super. hope it graded that high for you and you were happy........

 

Oh Man, this is off topic but stay away from Comix32. I never paid that @#%@#. My ONLY negative was for a $2,325 auction that I won and never paid cause he refused to send me the scans of the key books I won. And the scans they did sent me of Hulk 181 was so overgraded. I'll happily take my ONLY neg than risk flushing $2k down the drain. I emailed former buyers of high priced auctions that they won from Comix32 and same MO....crappy books.

 

Anyway, this # 94 is not from Comix32.

 

WQ

 

[supapimp]

nice book, 9.0-9.2

[Aces]

Nice book!

 

The bottom spine corner does have some small damage, but it might still pull a 9.4!

 

Check the attachment for a scan where you can see the whole book at once for QP inseption.

 

 

What do you mean?

 

Quality of Production (basicly centering).

It's easier to judge if you can see the whole book at one glance.

 

I think you have a shot at a 9.4 there.

I had a ASM 120 with 2 little creases and small damage at one corner just like yours and it got a 9.4. It also had some dist ink too...

I can't see it getting worse than a 9.2 unless they find something to hate on the inside or back cover.

 

Get it graded and keep your fingers crossed!

[uclapeterg]

8.5 or 9.0.

 

[joe_collector]

CGC 9.2 and (if some of those small scuffs are on the bag) a shot at 9.4.