GUESS the grade - XMEN 41

[etanick]

Ok, not PLOD so it is clean. The front cover hid a lot of "flaws" so it look like a 9.2 in front. The back is where the "flaws" revealed themselves.

 

 

 

[c-mack]

8.0?

[tigers comics]

Nice comic. 7.5

[AGGIEZ]

I'm guessing 8.5

[crazyhips]

7.0 due to staining

[Mio]

6.5 looks pretty brown.

[LloydJBailey]

8.0/8.5

[bedrockcomics]

I'd give it a fine if I graded to sell in store..So I'd say 6.0

[Twistty1]

I was going to say 5.5 or 6.0 myself..

[AGGIEZ]

OK, I change my guess to 4.5

[gaz2810i]

7.0

[slseals]

Is that tanning, also, what is the blue/gray area above/around Norman Rockwell's name at the top? Is that some kind of water damage, or even mold? Front looks great, like you said, but I'd say 6.0-6.5?

[etanick]

Mio,

 

the winner at 6.5

 

I think if the back cover was just even tan instead of having the rust bleed thru and other issues, the book could have been a 8.0 or even higher. The spine was near perfect as well as the corners...damn shame.

 

this was a mistake that i won't make again since this book was in my very first submit to CGC.

 

 

[oakman29]

Nice comic. 7.5

(thumbs u