PGM Hopalong Cassidy and the Mad Barber 1951 SOTI

[Fantastic Thor]

Let me know what you think.

Thinking of sending it away to CGC.

Cheers

 

T

 

[/img]

 

 

[/img]

[Mio]

I don't see many faults at all... 9.0+?

[Fantastic Thor]

any thoughts?

 

t

[TFL-migration]

9.0 Possible 9.2 In hand. IMHO

[Fantastic Thor]

[AJD]

Not sure about this - what are the spots on the back cover, stains, 'age marks' or defects in the paper as produced?

 

Depending on the nature of the spots, I'm thinking 8.0 which, as a collector of giveaways myself, isn't too shabby with these cheaply produced things.

[Dr_Neff]

7.5 I don't feel top right corner FC is that strong.

[ARK]

8.0/8.5 I'm with the doctor on the corner and the front spine looks like it has a light reading crease and the spots on the BC. Beautiful old givaway.

[Fantastic Thor]

Thanks for the grades...

 

I think the brown spots are just from Cheap paper.

The small reading crease is a good pickup, and probably keeping it from a 9.0...

Will have to send it to CGC for a look!

 

Cheers

 

TG99

[Fantastic Thor]

This one Came back an 8.0