PGM: Batman 10

[ImSeeker-migration]

Hi, still trying to figure out this site, looks fascinating.

 

Where would be an appropriate place to start a thread called: "When should you CGC grade a comic?" [asked in two other threads, but maybe not everyone will look at all three]

 

That asked, I have 3 PGMs - I think I read somewhere you shouldn't put more than 3 in a day. If it's too many, kindly let me know.

 

------------------

 

 

-----------------

 

[etanick]

6.0? very nice and WTTB

[ImSeeker-migration]

Thanks for the welcome.

 

I look forward to participating; more so than just asking for grading...

[ROBTOTHEC]

Looks like a 5.0, possible GA bump to 5.5!

[ImSeeker-migration]

What's a GA bump? (Golden Age bump???)

[ARK]

I'm with 5.5. Great Book!

[SteveLRoberts5]

What's a GA bump? (Golden Age bump???)

 

Bump up the grade due to the age of the book. Books from the thirties, forties and perhaps even the fifties (early fifties?) would qualify. I don't know if it's a fact or can be proven; it's just collectors' perception. Anyway, I love your Batman 15; I'd give it a 5.5 or 6.0. Great copy!

[143ksk]

6.0/6.5

[tortoise]

solid 5.0 imo

really nice book!

 

[gaz2810i]

Nice book mate, 5.5 from me and WTTB

[Boozad]

5.5, it may push a 6.0 but I'd be more comfortable with lower grade. Beautiful book.

 

WTTB (thumbs u

[ImSeeker-migration]

Thanks - I graded it 5.5 myself, nice to see myself in good company.

[Point Five]

Thanks - I graded it 5.5 myself, nice to see myself in good company.

...My guess as well.

Welcome to the boards! (thumbs u

[trmoore54]

6.0/6.5

 

143ksk knows how to grade GA books...I'm gonna go 6.0...

 

and WTTB!

[G.A.tor]

What's a GA bump? (Golden Age bump???)

 

Bump up the grade due to the age of the book. Books from the thirties, forties and perhaps even the fifties (early fifties?) would qualify. I don't know if it's a fact or can be proven; it's just collectors' perception. Anyway, I love your Batman 15; I'd give it a 5.5 or 6.0. Great copy!

it is a perception, but doesn't exist real world ... the grade is the grade (IMO)

now, taken into consideration in the grading process is the type of paper used, the production process of the time (obviously comics produced in the 30's don't have the same production techniques as those from the 60's or 90's, etc)... but it is all relative

 

and in this case, I think a 6.0 from what I can see is fair

[ImSeeker-migration]

Go Gators!

 

(I'm a Florida grad)

[mrlatko]

4.5/5.0 due to that dust or oxidation shadow on FC.

[Marvelfangirl]

5.5 great GA book

 

WTTB (hope you survive the asylum )

[G.A.tor]

Go Gators!

 

(I'm a Florida grad)

me too...class of 89 (and 2nd degree in 90 ) (thumbs u

[JohnT]

5.0 due to reading crease.