-Silver Age DC Superhero-SURVIVOR SERIES-Round 4

[thirdgreenham]

as Showcase 79 was voted off - i guess the forum doesn't like well-drawn images of beautiful women against a gorgeous green background - i'm out of this thing.

 

 

thanks for the hard work though!

 

You are welcome.

 

I'm sure you can form opinions on the remaining ones, though. Here's to hoping you secretly come back and continue to vote.

 

Andy

[JohnT]

Looks like JLA is going to take a big hit this time.

[Aman619]

It's not the authors fault its the poor polling feature limitations built into the forums.

 

It would be easier if the "master poll" was split into multiple polls within each round thread by genre or comic title leading to more distinct and significant rounds that pit title vs. title and/or genre vs. genre rather than just "dump thirty issues" type polls.

 

 

thanx for understanding!

[mrlatko]

I don't see GL #76 here. I guess that proves it is the 1st bronze age DC comic?

 

[icouldbe]

Right now 29 covers have 11+ votes with the highest cover now at 15.

 

There are only 3 covers that don't have 4 votes and they each have 3 votes.

 

My underdog for the tourney was JLA 72 with a Kubert Hawkgirl cover that unfortunately lost in the 3rd round.

[JLA_ALL_THE_WAY]

my guess of the top 10 (in no order):

 

B&B #28 - personally prefer #30

Supes #199 - first race...duh?

Flash #123 - Crisis intro/ 1st GA x-over

SC #61 - cosmic...and cosmically funny

GL #73 - I think the silhouette may beat out #8 or #40, depending on how many female voters

SC #22 - hype

JLA #21 - if enough GA voters; if not, then #9

SC #4 - nuff said

MIS #82 - coolness factor

 

Andy, if you're worried my picks may unfairly affect voting, feel free to delete. I'll understand; just trying to stir up interest here. And thanx again.

 

Rick

 

JLA_all_the_way, your picks are not going to affect how the voting goes. I mean, just look at the books you chose.

 

Just kidding.

 

 

 

 

...well, no, I'm not.

 

Hey Andy, I noticed you didn't counter with your own list...? Scared?

 

What about you others? Are there a bunch of Nancys on these boards?? And no cop out like "It's too early" or "I don't want to put a bullseye on my picks."

 

C'mon sweethearts, man up.

 

[skypinkblu]

my guess of the top 10 (in no order):

 

B&B #28 - personally prefer #30

Supes #199 - first race...duh?

Flash #123 - Crisis intro/ 1st GA x-over

SC #61 - cosmic...and cosmically funny

GL #73 - I think the silhouette may beat out #8 or #40, depending on how many female voters

SC #22 - hype

JLA #21 - if enough GA voters; if not, then #9

SC #4 - nuff said

MIS #82 - coolness factor

 

Andy, if you're worried my picks may unfairly affect voting, feel free to delete. I'll understand; just trying to stir up interest here. And thanx again.

 

Rick

 

JLA_all_the_way, your picks are not going to affect how the voting goes. I mean, just look at the books you chose.

 

Just kidding.

 

 

 

 

...well, no, I'm not.

 

Hey Andy, I noticed you didn't counter with your own list...? Scared?

 

What about you others? Are there a bunch of Nancys on these boards?? And no cop out like "It's too early" or "I don't want to put a bullseye on my picks."

 

C'mon sweethearts, man up.

 

 

I don't know of ANY Nancys, but there seem to be a whole bunch of "Ricks" :shrug:

[JLA_ALL_THE_WAY]

Touche!

 

All right, that's one. Any others?

 

 

Rick

[RockMyAmadeus]

ALL The Batmans were voted off...?

 

You people suck.

 

[selegue]

A little chitchat

 

I'll be shocked if JLA 9, one of my favorite SA covers and maybe my favorite of the run, gets the boot while Flash 174, a Spirit swipe and not that well executed, survives.

 

Overall, I'm pleased to see a lot of my favorites still in the running. I'm surprised at all the comments that it's too difficult to vote. Open two tabs or two windows and pop back and forth. What's so hard about that?

 

Fun contest.

 

Jack

 

 

[thirdgreenham]

ALL The Batmans were voted off...?

 

You people suck.

 

 

Um...no. It seems that Batman sucks, though.

[thirdgreenham]

my guess of the top 10 (in no order):

 

B&B #28 - personally prefer #30

Supes #199 - first race...duh?

Flash #123 - Crisis intro/ 1st GA x-over

SC #61 - cosmic...and cosmically funny

GL #73 - I think the silhouette may beat out #8 or #40, depending on how many female voters

SC #22 - hype

JLA #21 - if enough GA voters; if not, then #9

SC #4 - nuff said

MIS #82 - coolness factor

 

Andy, if you're worried my picks may unfairly affect voting, feel free to delete. I'll understand; just trying to stir up interest here. And thanx again.

 

Rick

 

JLA_all_the_way, your picks are not going to affect how the voting goes. I mean, just look at the books you chose.

 

Just kidding.

 

 

 

 

...well, no, I'm not.

 

Hey Andy, I noticed you didn't counter with your own list...? Scared?

 

What about you others? Are there a bunch of Nancys on these boards?? And no cop out like "It's too early" or "I don't want to put a bullseye on my picks."

 

C'mon sweethearts, man up.

 

 

Yeah, I am scared, alright? You got a problem with that? You just had to get me angry, didn't you. :censored:

 

Top 10 in no order whatsoever:

 

Brave and the Bold 44

Challengers of the Unknown 11

Mystery In Space 54

Sea Devils 2

Sea Devils 9

Strange Adventures 212

Sea Devils 10

JLA 9

Brave and the Bold 34

Brave and the Bold 28

 

[skypinkblu]

Andy, thanks for taking the time to do this, I know it must have taken you a while! It's fun.

 

and thanks for being a "guy" Rick;)

 

My favorites

 

Showcase 22

Brave and the Bold

28

34

44

JLA 9

Showcase 34

and Wonder Woman 108 There are other Wonder Woman covers I prefer,but that one is haunting.

 

It was not hard to click off the choices, but it was hard to chose ones to get rid of.

[Senormac]

ALL The Batmans were voted off...?

 

You people suck.

 

 

Um...no. It seems that Batman sucks, though.

 

[JohnT]

my guess of the top 10 (in no order):

 

B&B #28 - personally prefer #30

Supes #199 - first race...duh?

Flash #123 - Crisis intro/ 1st GA x-over

SC #61 - cosmic...and cosmically funny

GL #73 - I think the silhouette may beat out #8 or #40, depending on how many female voters

SC #22 - hype

JLA #21 - if enough GA voters; if not, then #9

SC #4 - nuff said

MIS #82 - coolness factor

 

Andy, if you're worried my picks may unfairly affect voting, feel free to delete. I'll understand; just trying to stir up interest here. And thanx again.

 

Rick

 

JLA_all_the_way, your picks are not going to affect how the voting goes. I mean, just look at the books you chose.

 

Just kidding.

 

 

 

 

...well, no, I'm not.

 

Hey Andy, I noticed you didn't counter with your own list...? Scared?

 

What about you others? Are there a bunch of Nancys on these boards?? And no cop out like "It's too early" or "I don't want to put a bullseye on my picks."

 

C'mon sweethearts, man up.

 

 

I guess I'm a sucker for the iconic first appearances...

 

Action 242

BB 28

BB 34

Showcase 17

Showcase 22

Showcase 34

JLA 3

MIS 55

MIS 65

GL 8

[RockMyAmadeus]

ALL The Batmans were voted off...?

 

You people suck.

 

 

Um...no. It seems that Batman sucks, though.

 

 

 

Pffffft..

 

Whateva.

 

I'm going to go hug my Batman collection now...

 

[JLA_ALL_THE_WAY]

Alright! I knew with a lil prodding I could get some list action going. 'C'ourse, I won't criticize other people's choices. I'm too much of a gentleman for that.

 

Bang Boom!

 

Keep it up boys & Girls.

 

Rick