PGM superman 14

[joker-fish]

I know this is a low grade copy, but I dont know what to grade it as. There is some glue on the spine that I have circled in the 2nd pic, some funky tape residue, a detached centerfold, and a bit of glue on the bottomiside cover. I just dont know where to put this as far as resto is considered

 

[tortoise]

1.0 at highest imo

 

[joker-fish]

I was thinking 1.5-1.8 on a good day

[ft88]

It probably is restored but I've always felt that didn't matter on sub 2.0 books. I'd guess CGC would give it a 1.0 but I've always felt they have a pretty wide range at the 1.0 level and this book looks pretty good. They tend to hammer books that have paper loss and loose pages.

[tortoise]

now that i look at it more it might squeak out a 1.5(i still think it gets a 1.0) i dont see 1.8 though

[joker-fish]

all I see is my first golden age supes book

[tortoise]

all I see is my first golden age supes book

 

[DR.FRANKENSTEIN-migration]

1.0 .....but a nice 1.0 congratulations!!!

[Mac Man]

It's 100% complete so that will keep it out of the 0.5 POOR range.

 

It also has a rather substantial chunk missing out of the front cover as well as the first few wraps along with what appears to be either tape or tape residue. If it were just one of these two flaws, I could see a possible 1.5 FR/GD.

 

With both of these two major defects combined with the traditional wear 'n tear flaws and defects of a book below GD+ (smaller missing pieces, tears, spine stresses, etc), this book is a solid 1.0 to me.

 

Presents well enough and looks to be readable--MY KIND OF BOOK!

[Point Five]

Yep yep... technical 1.0, but for a black-cover book in Fair I've definitely seen much worse. (thumbs u Congrats!

 

 

[rjpb]

1.0 - slight resto is irrelevant in this grade.