PGM: Superman #233

[AlexH]

Off-white to cream pages.

 

Honest opinions appreciated.

 

 

[John R]

nice neal adams cover...imo 2.5

[pietaster-migration]

3.5

[TFL-migration]

4.0 IMHO. 2.5, Seriously??? No way this book is a 2.5. Take a look at slabbed 2.5 books and see the difference in the grades.. My nephew Porcupine48 has a book coming to him in a 2.0 slab. The cover is detached, and is in poorer condition than the book in this thread. It is a Strange Tales #1 BTW!!

[Point Five]

3.5

(thumbs u

 

Nice colors, but methinks there's just too much creasing & wear on both sides to go higher.

[marvelcollector]

3.5...spine wear, creases, soiling on BC...too much for a straight VG IMO...

[silverseeker]

3.5 sounds right to me too, but I could see it getting a 4.0...

[Spider-Variant]

Off-white to cream pages.

 

Honest opinions appreciated.

 

I think you could really work on your hygiene.

 

Oh, wait, you meant about the comic.

 

I'm going 4.0, guess I like it a little better than most.

[AlexH]

Thanks everyone.

[ARK]

I'm with a 3.5 also.

[topofthetotem]

3.5 sounds right to me too, but I could see it getting a 4.0...

(thumbs u I agree.

[Peter Loves Gwen]

I agree with 3.5, depending on how the staining knocks it down.