Rate the Blanks/Sketch covers again. (all Marvel)

[LordBurke81]

seeing as how all I see is a bunch of ranting and raving about how bad or good the sketch covers are, can someone rate the covers for me accordingly? color & black & white - perhaps on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the best.

 

 

X-Men #1 -

color (copics & pantone) -

black & white (sharpie & sharpie silver) -

 

Avengers #1-

color -

b & w -

 

Avengers #1 2nd Print (gray logo a top) -

color -

b & w -

 

New Avengers #1 -

color - -

b & w -

 

Marvels Project #1 -

color -

b & w -

 

Amazing Spider-Man #648 -

color -

b & w -

 

Uncanny X-Force #1 -

color -

b & w-

 

Wolverine #1 -

color -

b & 2 -

 

Dark Avengers #1 -

color -

b & w -

 

Secret Invasion #1 (non glossy) -

color -

b & w -

 

 

if i missed any, please feel free to add them & thanks for the help.

 

[Menace]

[Menace]

Avengers #7

 

Image United #1 <--- people hate this book

 

Fallen Son #?

 

BOOM blanks, incredibles, darkwing duck etc.

 

Powers #11

 

The Return Civil War #1

 

Shi-year of the Dragon

 

Shi Year of the Serpent

 

Man with no Name #1

 

ASM #36 Black

 

[NYComics]

seeing as how all I see is a bunch of ranting and raving about how bad or good the sketch covers are, can someone rate the covers for me accordingly? color & black & white - perhaps on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the best.

 

 

X-Men #1 - Excellent all around 10

color (copics & pantone) -

black & white (sharpie & sharpie silver) -

 

Avengers #1- 10

color -

b & w -

 

Avengers #1 2nd Print (gray logo a top) -8

color - Not so great w/ color

b & w -

 

New Avengers #1 - 8 (Just dont love the layout)

color - Fine

b & w - Fine

 

Marvels Project #1 - 8 Hate the layout

color - Fine

b & w - Fine

 

Amazing Spider-Man #648 - 10! Waited for this forever!

color - Not so great I hear.....but dont know for sure

b & w - Fine

 

Uncanny X-Force #1 - 8 Love the layout. Have not gotten any done yet.

color -

b & w-

 

Wolverine #1 - 8

color - BAD

b & 2 -

 

Dark Avengers #1 - 10+ My favorite blank cover along with ASM blank

color - Great

b & w -Great

 

Secret Invasion #1 (non glossy) - 8

color - Tough but can be done

b & w - fine

 

 

if i missed any, please feel free to add them & thanks for the help.

[Chespirito]

Avengers #7

 

Image United #1 <--- people hate this book

 

Fallen Son #?

 

BOOM blanks, incredibles, darkwing duck etc.

 

Powers #11

 

The Return Civil War #1

 

Shi-year of the Dragon

 

Shi Year of the Serpent

 

Man with no Name #1

 

ASM #36 Black

Most of the mentioned ones are cool, but Man with no name? Seriously, that cover suckz! As far as Powers 11, that one is most certainly a good one, I haven't even seen another one being used...

[A-DONIS]

Avengers 7, X-Men 7, X-Force, all Wolverine Blanks, and ASM 648 are good for BW sketches only.

 

Don't bet on Marvel making quality blanks like Avengers 1.

[Chespirito]

Will someone ever use the Black cover Witchblade 54?? It's perfect!

[Secret Son]

Didn't we just do this recently?

[Turtle]

Didn't we just do this recently?

 

Both here and in comics general.

[A-DONIS]

Maybe someone's expecting a different answer?

[Secret Son]

We'll have all new posts coming soon since con season will be heating up soon.

[somewhereintexas]

Didn't we just do this recently?

 

Both here and in comics general.

 

Maybe he wants the responses in one place instead of spread across one or more threads.

 

I quit buying the sketch covers after ASM, but it seems like there was a second Wolverine blank that was declared suitable for coloring by Anthony Castrillo.

[Secret Son]

The information was in one place and then again in another forum and then back here yet again.

 

I don't mind seeing the same topics brought up, it happens, but it's way too soon for this one.

 

 

[3319comics]

Wasnt there a Battlestar Galactica blank?