Captain America Comics #58

[silvers]

I was hoping I could get some feedback on this book! The book is super nice but does have the stain that you can see on the back cover. Wanted to see what everyone thinks as far as a grade!

 

 

 

[MR SigS]

I always feel bad seeing a post with several viewers but 0 responses. LIKE MY 3D SUPERMAN (not one opinion?) Anyway...

Holy crud, that's a nice looking book even with the stain. But it probably does hurt it quite a bit. I doubt higher than 5.0- but I'm not educated enough on how CGC treats stains. Without it 8.0 easy, IMHO

[NYNick]

Looks like that stain made it to the front cover also. So did the one on the bottom. Still a nice book. 5.0

[marvelcollector]

Positive attributes push it to a 3.5, despite the stain...

[kelholt]

I am in for a 5.0 too.

 

[mystrymachine]

Positive attributes push it to a 3.5, despite the stain...

 

I agree. 3.5 seems about right.