Question on the CGC label!

[phobalicious]

For those experts out there, can you help me for this question:

 

What Label do I get if I have a blank cover book sketched by 1 artist (unwitnessed by CGC) and have it signed by different artist (the creator of sketched character) witnessed by CGC rep? Will it get Yellow Signature Series label or Green Qualify or something else? What Label if it's inked/colored by an artist from Signature Series Opportunity?

 

Thanks!

[James Howlett]

It will be yellow but the first sketch will be counted as a defect towards the grade.

[mschmidt]

If a 9.8 book goes to a 7.5 due to a single signature on the front cover, I can't even imagine what kind of grade drop you'd get from a full (unverified) sketch

[Green]

Although inwoulda be curious as to how cgc would handle an unverified sketch that had ink and coloring witnessed.

[TheLiamSturgess]

I could be wrong, but my guess would be .5 :shrug: That, or NG but my vote is on the .5.

[Chespirito]

Although inwoulda be curious as to how cgc would handle an unverified sketch that had ink and coloring witnessed.

I have had that done before, they will grade the book and have the sketch as a flaw...if the book is 9.8, per say, the book will likely get 5.5-7.5 yellow label

[.Troy]

Although inwoulda be curious as to how cgc would handle an unverified sketch that had ink and coloring witnessed.

 

Interesting question, I to would be curious how it would come back.

 

 

[3319comics]

how does cgc ss know about the original sketch under the inking and color?

[DrWatson]

There is no SS label for the underlying sketch..

[seanfingh]

This book was penciled and inked by Boardie Rino. When I got it, it was not colored.

 

 

This sketch was on the back, and I loved it as much or more than the main image.

 

 

So I had Mike Champion color it at Chicago, and slabbed it so i could see both sketches. I specifically did not request SS, because the authentication was of no import. I am very pleased with the decision. I think it would look dumb in a 2.0 yellow label holder saying "sketch of Vision on cover colored by Michael Champion.