FF4: Grade it!

[Darthdiesel]

[LordRahl]

NICE!!! 9.2?

[divad]

We are not worthy!

 

Nice book Darth! What's that little tweak just to the right of the Thing's head? Scanner relic? Guy jumpin off the top of the Baxter building? Jack Kirby's booger? I give it a solid 9.0 - it's a beauty!!!

[Aces]

 

He's mad!

It must have gotten a grade.

 

8.5? 8.0?

 

Looks at least 9.0 to me...

[Darthdiesel]

We are not worthy!

 

Nice book Darth! What's that little tweak just to the right of the Thing's head? Scanner relic? Guy jumpin off the top of the Baxter building? Jack Kirby's booger?

 

I always thought it was Mothra!

 

I'm going with big mutant bird on this one

[PovertyRow]

I'd say a min 9.2. My inclination is to a 9.4 based on the lack of defects I can find beyond that seeming spine wrinkle rigt by Reed's knee.

[FFB]

I can't grade it. I am too faint.

[FFB]

I would give it a 9.4, maybe a 9.2 for non-color-breaking spine stress. It is freaking gorgeous. That is one of the nicest copies in existence.

 

Whose book is that???

[ghengishahn]

hmm...was that the 9.4 copy that was on ebay not to long ago...sold for like $14,000 or something like that. Regardless, im jealous!

[Silver Surfer]

Darth,

 

Sweet fancy Moses. A solid 9.2 I would say. One of my grails, you are fortunate sir.

[comicmankev]

[nik]

WOW, 9.2 at the very minimum

[ArAich]

Alright...What's wrong with it?!?!?!?... I'm in at 8.5 cause of the freakin' corners...

[Red Hook]

Before I scrolled down to see the other answers, I came up with 9.2. It's hard not to give a book like that a little nudge upwards........

[comicmankev]

I'd give it a 9.2-9.4. I think I see a slight color touch as well as a tear seal. It may be just a theory, but I think the cover has been reinforced

[Moriarty]

8.0 due to rounded corners & fading/sheen

[kryptonitecomics]

9.0.....it's hard to tell from the scan, but it looks like their is a loss of gloss and some slight fading on the cover. It may be that the bok is flat and not reflecting light, but It still looks like a 9.0 to me.

[Fan4Fan]

I'd say a min 9.2. My inclination is to a 9.4 based on the lack of defects I can find beyond that seeming spine wrinkle rigt by Reed's knee.

 

Could be another by Reed's waist...

 

Still... looks like easy 9.2 territory.

 

Thanks,

Fan4Fan

[Ze-man]

a solid 9.0

 

9.2 if graded on a curve.

[uclapeterg]

I agree with this grade and also due to the fact that Darth's unhappy with it.

 

8.0 due to rounded corners & fading/sheen

 

Darth, what are you doing with early SA FF??? Is it yours?