PGM: Archie 11

[CycleGirl]

Please note, the cover is detached at both staples. The book is complete.

 

 

Thanks for your help.

[skypinkblu]

Haven't seen you in a while:)

 

I'd say Good to no better than Good+ with the detached cover. I always think of theblackhand when I see that book:)

[crazyhips]

2.5 because of detached cover. Present much higher, maybe 4.0/4.5

[CycleGirl]

Haven't seen you in a while:)

 

I'd say Good to no better than Good+ with the detached cover. I always think of theblackhand when I see that book:)

 

[Aces]

Old School Overstreet would say no higher than Good/Good+ for any book with detached cover.

But CGC rules are stealth and they tend to be a little more generous to lower grade books with nice over-all presentation.

 

3.0/3.5

[143ksk]

Old School Overstreet would say no higher than Good/Good+ for any book with detached cover.

But CGC rules are stealth and they tend to be a little more generous to lower grade books with nice over-all presentation.

 

3.0/3.5

 

I agree.

[divad]

Old School Overstreet would say no higher than Good/Good+ for any book with detached cover.

But CGC rules are stealth and they tend to be a little more generous to lower grade books with nice over-all presentation.

 

3.0/3.5

 

I agree.

 

Agreed (except that 3.0 is generally the upper CGC limit with a detached cover.)

[NuffSaid57]

I am in the 3.0/3.5 camp

[ARK]

3.0 for me.

Cool book!

[Wilson3d]

3.0 for me.

Cool book!

 

+1

[CycleGirl]

Thanks for all the help everyone. I was pretty happy to find this book in just about any condition at all. I think that I may go ahead and send it in with the rest of my CGC sub. I wasn't going to bother if the consensus was 2.0 or lower. Fortunately it was sold to me as a GD, so if I do better it will be a bump.

[DR.X]

Old School Overstreet would say no higher than Good/Good+ for any book with detached cover.

But CGC rules are stealth and they tend to be a little more generous to lower grade books with nice over-all presentation.

 

3.0/3.5

 

I agree.

 

Agreed (except that 3.0 is generally the upper CGC limit with a detached cover.)

 

O.K. I just learned something here. Like Aces say's when you look in the older version of the grading guide I think 2.0 is the cut-off with both staples detached. I'm glad I know this now that CGC is a little more forgiving on detached covers. Do they note that on the label?

[divad]

Old School Overstreet would say no higher than Good/Good+ for any book with detached cover.

But CGC rules are stealth and they tend to be a little more generous to lower grade books with nice over-all presentation.

 

3.0/3.5

 

I agree.

 

Agreed (except that 3.0 is generally the upper CGC limit with a detached cover.)

 

O.K. I just learned something here. Like Aces say's when you look in the older version of the grading guide I think 2.0 is the cut-off with both staples detached. I'm glad I know this now that CGC is a little more forgiving on detached covers. Do they note that on the label?

 

Yes, I have a sweet SA Batman (first SA app of the Penguin) . . . let me see if I can pull up the scan from my archives.