The Daily Grade (Part 2): Bronze Iron Man

[divad]

How about this one?

 

 

[jimm94]

9.6, but maybe only 9.4 due to the slightly rounded corners on BC. Gorgeous!

[osborn_fr]

9.6, but maybe only 9.4 due to the slightly rounded corners on BC. Gorgeous!

 

Ditto.

I love this cover ! I own a 9.4 copy of this book too.

[Fan4Fan]

9.4

[FFB]

9.2 due to rounded corners. Still gorgeous!

[divad]

9.2 due to rounded corners. Still gorgeous!

 

They are not "rounded" guys - they are just slightly formed over the interior pages, due to the fact there is tiniest bit of overhang.

 

"Rounded corners" come from wear - this book exhibits no wear whatsoever - try again!

 

It's a solid 9.6 and who would you rather sleep with? M. J. Watson or Pepper Potts?

[jimm94]

I stand chastised. 9.6 it is. Pepper Potts

[davidking623]

9.2

 

Davidking623

[uclapeterg]

Is that a round crease on the left top? If so, 9.0; if not, 9.2

[divad]

Is that a round crease on the left top? If so, 9.0; if not, 9.2

 

No, the left edge of the black ink wavers slightly. And those white flecks are actually stars - part of the art. Together they give the impression of a light crease in the scan.

[Aces]

9.2 at least

Maybe 9.4

 

[divad]

If anyone happens to be into Iron Man btw, this book's been listed:

 

Iron Man #69

 

[savagetales]

9.4

[deathlok]

9.0-9.2

[uclapeterg]

If anyone happens to be into Iron Man btw, this book's been listed:

 

Iron Man #69

 

 

Why do you ask for opur opinions on a book's grade, then don't listen to any of us when you list a book?

[divad]

Hey Pete,

 

I do. I value your opinions very much. You, however, do not have the advantage of having the book in hand. You cannot accurately grade from a scan. If you could, we wouldn't have to send our books to CGC, just scan 'em on over!

 

[divad]

BTW, It's not like any of you guys are actually going to buy anything raw on eBay!

 

You can always PM me an offer, based on your grade of the book - I ALWAYS listen to offers!

[uclapeterg]

Ok, I'll give you cover price for the book.

 

BTW, Why are you posting the books on here in the first place? I agree it helps having the book in hand, but sometimes we can point out defects that a seller doesn't see or doesn't want to see.

[divad]

Ok, I'll give you cover price for the book.

 

I guess I don't listen THAT well!

 

BTW, Why are you posting the books on here in the first place?

 

It's fun, they're great books, and I LIKE you guys! Why are you here?

 

I agree it helps having the book in hand, but sometimes we can point out defects that a seller doesn't see or doesn't want to see.

 

Touche, and that's another reason I post up books. But, nothing was pointed out on this book, that I wasn't already aware of. In fact, the lower grades were made without salient comment.

 

[uclapeterg]

salient???

 

said another way, do you mean people actually give books a lower grade than you and don't back it up or say why it is?