PGM ASM 129

[bruce21wayne21]

Slab worthy?

 

 

[oakman29]

7.0 sure it's slab worthy. (thumbs u

[youmechooz]

7.0 sure it's slab worthy. (thumbs u

+1

[LanceRoten-migration]

7.5 here. I don't buy or collect slabbed comics however

[ARK]

7.0 sure it's slab worthy. (thumbs u

+1

 

+2

[bruce21wayne21]

This was just graded today by the cgc.

 

It got a 6.5

 

I thought sure it would be a 7.

[MR SigS]

CGC. They so funny.

 

I thought mine was a 6.0 and it came back 6.5 W

 

In fact, based on a comparison of our books I was going to say yours looked 5.5-6.0

 

Yup. They so funny.

[vaillant]

6.5 is understandable. Too many creases, although small, to go towards the VF.

Maybe it would have been better sold not CGC certified?

[bruce21wayne21]

CGC. They so funny.

 

I thought mine was a 6.0 and it came back 6.5 W

 

In fact, based on a comparison of our books I was going to say yours looked 5.5-6.0

 

Yup. They so funny.

The interesting thing is for all the moderns I sent in they graded higher than my guess. They graded this one ASM 300 an 9.8 and I thought it would be 9.4 or 9.6 if I was lucky. They graded another 9.6 people here said 9.0 to 9.2 a 9.4 if I was lucky.

 

6.5 is understandable. Too many creases, although small, to go towards the VF.

Maybe it would have been better sold not CGC certified?

Even with the cost of getting it graded I wouldn't have been able to sell it as an FN+ raw and make it enough to make grading like a mistake.

 

Honestly, after time has passed my grading skill is better and I can see how it got a 6.5. This scan wasn't one of my better ones. Its unnaturally bright. I will take a pic of the slab when its back to me. You can see more how it would look in hand as opposed to this scan where it looks off.