All Select #1

[SNiPER]

I'm assuming this would come back blue w/ slight CT since it's not really improving the grade.

 

Grade and thoughts anyone?

Thanks,

 

I posed the question in the resto thread but no answer yet.

May send it to Matt for opinion on removing if possible vs. keeping as is.

 

 

 

[tortoise]

Cool book, I'd call it Fine (6.0) Slight A

[oakman29]

5.0/5.5 slight A (thumbs u

[Moe's Attic]

I'd be interested to see if this would be considered moderate or slight restoration because of its size. It looks like an apparent 5.5 to 6.0 to me regardless.

[Cimm]

4.5 Slight (A)

 

The back cover knocks this out of Fine contention, for me...

[rjpb]

The book presents very nicely, but unfortunately the color touch is obvious and amateur enough, that I'd think the grade would be similar to what it would be unrestored. It looks like it was done to cover up a tape pull, which had it been left alone, would probably have made the book a 4.0. Looking at the pictures in the resto thread, with the bleed through, my guess is this would come back as a 4.0 PLOD Slight (A), maybe a 4.5. A book of this value is probably worth sending to Matt for at least an opinion - as to removal or proper restoration, and probable CGC result of either.

[roulette44]

5.5 slight (A)

[SNiPER]

Thanks for the comments guys!