GRADE THIS ASM 136

[THE_BEYONDER]

 

BACK COVER

 

 

 

[supapimp]

7.5 QP -5

[divad]

Very nice book. Unfortunately the wanker of a spine crease and the two minute edge tears to the back cover would keep it from higher than a 8.0. I hate to give a book this nice a low grade, but:

 

7.5

[supapimp]

whoa [!@#%^&^]! we actually agree on a grade?

[divad]

whoa [!@#%^&^]! we actually agree on a grade?

 

not the first time . . . I thought I was gonna be first on this one!

[THE_BEYONDER]

One of the pages in the centerfold of the book also has a 1" tear. Would such a defect cause further deductions....or would CGC simply qualify it?

[Mephisto]

One of the pages in the centerfold of the book also has a 1" tear. Would such a defect cause further deductions....or would CGC simply qualify it?

 

Might note it on the label... I don't see it getting a green label for it.

[divad]

One of the pages in the centerfold of the book also has a 1" tear. Would such a defect cause further deductions....or would CGC simply qualify it?

 

At the staple or at the edge?

[THE_BEYONDER]

One of the pages in the centerfold of the book also has a 1" tear. Would such a defect cause further deductions....or would CGC simply qualify it?

 

At the staple or at the edge?

 

Top edge

[divad]

One of the pages in the centerfold of the book also has a 1" tear. Would such a defect cause further deductions....or would CGC simply qualify it?

 

At the staple or at the edge?

 

Top edge

 

Then, I agree with Mephisto.

[THE_BEYONDER]

One of the pages in the centerfold of the book also has a 1" tear. Would such a defect cause further deductions....or would CGC simply qualify it?

 

At the staple or at the edge?

 

Top edge

 

Then, I agree with Mephisto.

 

How much of a deduction for the tear?

[uclapeterg]

I think this book will get a 7.0 and I think CGC will just mention the tear on the label.

[Stout1]

A solid 7.0 A nice book..

[Mephisto]

I think this book will get a 7.0 and I think CGC will just mention the tear on the label.

 

Yeah I'm not so sure they will really take off for the tear. From what I have seen unless it's uber high the interior pages don't have that big of an effect unless it's something major or a huge tear. Does the tear even go into any panels?

[THE_BEYONDER]

I think this book will get a 7.0 and I think CGC will just mention the tear on the label.

 

Yeah I'm not so sure they will really take off for the tear. From what I have seen unless it's uber high the interior pages don't have that big of an effect unless it's something major or a huge tear. Does the tear even go into any panels?

I just checked....

 

It's a two-page splash page...and the tear(which is actually about an inch and a half) cuts into the art by about an inch.

[DiceX]

7.0

Another quarter inch and you wouldn't have to include the back cover scan.

Most of it's already on the front cover.

[Aces]

7.0

 

I'm being a little harsh because of the tear.

7.5 without it.

[divad]

I think this book will get a 7.0 and I think CGC will just mention the tear on the label.

 

Yeah I'm not so sure they will really take off for the tear. From what I have seen unless it's uber high the interior pages don't have that big of an effect unless it's something major or a huge tear. Does the tear even go into any panels?

I just checked....

 

It's a two-page splash page...and the tear(which is actually about an inch and a half) cuts into the art by about an inch.

 

Yeah, it's a killer splash page I recall - can you post it?

[divad]

7.0

Another quarter inch and you wouldn't have to include the back cover scan.

Most of it's already on the front cover.

 

You baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad!